issues
Thread
Date
Earlier messages
Later messages
Messages by Date
2025/09/19
Re: [I] Declare MaxScoreAccumulator and DocScoreEncoder as public [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/19
Re: [PR] Remove unnecessary `AbstractKnnVectorQuery.exactSearch()` [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/19
Re: [PR] Fix the build on missing .git [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/19
Re: [PR] deps(java): bump org.apache.rat:apache-rat from 0.14 to 0.16.1 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/19
Re: [PR] FirstPassGroupingCollector supports ignoring docs without group field [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/19
[PR] Fix the build on missing .git [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/19
Re: [PR] FirstPassGroupingCollector supports ignoring docs without group field [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Refactor FirstPassGroupingCollector to improve readability. (#15136) [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] build(deps): bump ruff from 0.12.7 to 0.12.11 in /dev-tools/scripts [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Update created version major [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Use TernaryLongHeap in NeighborQueue for faster vector search performance [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [I] IndexWriter.merge does not properly clean up merge reader instances [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Fix encoding selection logic in Lucene104PostingsWriter [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Bump block size of postings to 256. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [I] Switch over current scalar quantization formats to use `OptimizedScalarQuantizer` [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Relax Lucene Index Upgrade Policy to Allow Safe Upgrades Across Multi… [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks (reapplied) [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks (reapplied) [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
[PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks (reapplied) [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [I] ReleaseWizard throws bunch of datetime deprecation warnings [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [I] smokeTestRelease throws SyntaxWarning: invalid escape sequence [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [I] smokeTestRelease throws SyntaxWarning: invalid escape sequence [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [I] Switch over current scalar quantization formats to use `OptimizedScalarQuantizer` [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [I] ReleaseWizard throws bunch of datetime deprecation warnings [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
[I] smokeTestRelease throws SyntaxWarning: invalid escape sequence [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
[I] ReleaseWizard throws bunch of datetime deprecation warnings [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [I] Switch over current scalar quantization formats to use `OptimizedScalarQuantizer` [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Relax Lucene Index Upgrade Policy to Allow Safe Upgrades Across Multi… [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
[PR] Use git-ls-files as the source of file paths for license checks. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Refactoring HNSWGraphBuilder's API and adding more comments about concurrency [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/18
Re: [PR] Vectorise expand8 in ForUtil using JDK Vector API [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] Switch to a fixed CFS threshold [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
[PR] Optimize prefix sum [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] MergedByteVectorValues is missing increasing `lastOrd` when advancing. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Refactoring HNSWGraphBuilder's API and adding more comments about concurrency [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] TestTieredMergePolicy.testSimulateUpdates fails intermittently asserting segment infos [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Make `flatVectorsFormat` injectable in `Lucene99HnswVectorsFormat` to allow custom format and scorers [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Avoid reconstructing HNSW graphs during segment merging. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Fix conflict between #14863 and #15169 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Fix conflict between #14863 and #15169 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Add a new codec to implement OSQ for 4 and 8 bit quantized vectors [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
[PR] Fix conflict between #14863 and #15169 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Add a new codec to implement OSQ for 4 and 8 bit quantized vectors [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] Switch over current scalar quantization formats to use `OptimizedScalarQuantizer` [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Vectorise expand8 in ForUtil using JDK Vector API [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
[PR] Vectorise expand8 in ForUtil using JDK Vector API [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] Support multiple HNSW graphs backed by the same vectors [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] Stop duplicating per-segment work across segment partitions [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] Create a simple "real world" regexp benchmark [LUCENE-9986] [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
[I] Ways to implement prefetching in BKD trees [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] [Investigate] Specialize BytesRef for literal byte arrays to save 8 bytes [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
[PR] deps(java): bump com.gradle.common-custom-user-data-gradle-plugin from 2.3 to 2.4.0 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Fix encoding selection logic in Lucene104PostingsWriter [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Fix encoding selection logic in Lucene104PostingsWriter [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Use int-specific operations in PForUtil.encode() [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] Create a simple "real world" regexp benchmark [LUCENE-9986] [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] Remove apache-rat dependency completely? [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] deps(java): bump org.apache.groovy:groovy-all from 4.0.28 to 5.0.0 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
[I] PathHierarchyTokenizer to support multiple delimiters [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [I] [Investigate] Specialize BytesRef for literal byte arrays to save 8 bytes [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move more gradle plugins to java. Remove Apache Rat dependency. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] Move finishMerge to a finally block so it always runs [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/17
Re: [PR] FirstPassGroupingCollector supports ignoring docs without group field [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] deps(java): bump org.apache.groovy:groovy-all from 4.0.28 to 5.0.1 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [I] [Investigate] Specialize BytesRef for literal byte arrays to save 8 bytes [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] deps(java): bump com.gradle.common-custom-user-data-gradle-plugin from 2.3 to 2.4.0 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] Implement off-heap quantized scoring [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] Optimize a bit two more prefix sums. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] Add BandwidthCappedMergeScheduler for enforcing a global merge bandwidth cap [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] Make Lucene90 postings format to write FST off heap [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] Make Lucene90 postings format to write FST off heap [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] deps(java): bump org.apache.groovy:groovy-all from 4.0.28 to 5.0.0 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
[PR] deps(java): bump org.apache.groovy:groovy-all from 4.0.28 to 5.0.1 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
[I] Specialize BytesRef for literal byte arrays to save 8 bytes [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
[I] A new "Diversification" Type collector akin to FirstPassGroupingCollector [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
[I] ForUtil: Can we operate long instead of int to further speed up the encoding/decoding [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [I] Remove apache-rat dependency completely? [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] Implement off-heap quantized scoring [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
[I] Should we make TrieBuilder off-heap [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] Change instance checks for PerFieldKnnVectorsFormat.FieldsReader to a non-specific method [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
[PR] Change instance checks for PerFieldKnnVectorsFormat.FieldsReader to a non-specific method [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/16
Re: [PR] Change instance checks for PerFieldKnnVectorsFormat.FieldsReader to a non-specific method [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [I] Support multiple HNSW graphs backed by the same vectors [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [I] Smoke tester requiring Python 3.12+ [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Remove even more boolean success flags [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
[PR] Fix off by one error in Lucene99MemorySegmentFloatVectorScorer [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Add a new codec to implement OSQ for 4 and 8 bit quantized vectors [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] build: require Python 3.12+, add smoke-test Make target [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Add a new codec to implement OSQ for 4 and 8 bit quantized vectors [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Add a new codec to implement OSQ for 4 and 8 bit quantized vectors [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Make `flatVectorsFormat` injectable in `Lucene99HnswVectorsFormat` to allow custom format and scorers [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [I] Remove apache-rat dependency completely? [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [I] Remove apache-rat dependency completely? [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [I] Remove apache-rat dependency completely? [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
[I] Remove apache-rat dependency completely? [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] build: require Python 3.12+, add smoke-test Make target [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] build: require Python 3.12+, add smoke-test Make target [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Refactoring HNSWGraphBuilder's API and adding more comments about concurrency [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [I] Stop duplicating per-segment work across segment partitions [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Make `flatVectorsFormat` injectable in `Lucene99HnswVectorsFormat` to allow custom format and scorers [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Make `flatVectorsFormat` injectable in `Lucene99HnswVectorsFormat` to allow custom format and scorers [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Make `flatVectorsFormat` injectable in `Lucene99HnswVectorsFormat` to allow custom format and scorers [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/15
Re: [PR] Refactoring HNSWGraphBuilder's API and adding more comments about concurrency [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/14
Re: [PR] Refactoring HNSWGraphBuilder's API and adding more comments about concurrency [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/14
[PR] Refactoring HNSWGraphBuilder's API and adding more comments about concurrency [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/14
Re: [PR] Make FSTPostingFormat to build FST off-heap [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/14
Re: [PR] Implement off-heap quantized scoring [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/14
Re: [PR] FirstPassGroupingCollector supports ignoring docs without group field [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/13
Re: [I] Create a simple "real world" regexp benchmark [LUCENE-9986] [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/13
Re: [PR] Make FSTPostingFormat to build FST off-heap [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/13
Re: [PR] Make `flatVectorsFormat` injectable in `Lucene99HnswVectorsFormat` to allow custom format and scorers [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/13
Re: [PR] Adds new simplified rescorer API to [Float|Byte]VectorValues [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/13
Re: [PR] Add a new codec to implement OSQ for 4 and 8 bit quantized vectors [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/13
Re: [PR] Add a new codec to implement OSQ for 4 and 8 bit quantized vectors [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/13
[I] switch website to new ASF logo [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/13
Re: [PR] Add bulk scoring option to VectorScorer interface [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/13
Re: [PR] chore: Seal BitSet to only allow FixedBitSet and SparseFixedBitSet [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [PR] chore: Seal BitSet to only allow FixedBitSet and SparseFixedBitSet [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [PR] Implement off-heap quantized scoring [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [PR] Fix off by one error in Lucene99MemorySegmentFloatVectorScorer [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [PR] Fix off by one error in Lucene99MemorySegmentFloatVectorScorer [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [I] Test failure in TestFlatVectorScorer.testBulkScorerFloats [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [I] Parsing a regex with groups that may match empty strings seems to be incorrect sometimes [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [I] Nested Span Queries are buggy [LUCENE-7398] [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [I] Test failure in TestFlatVectorScorer.testBulkScorerFloats [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [PR] Fix off by one error in Lucene99MemorySegmentFloatVectorScorer [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [PR] Fix off by one error in Lucene99MemorySegmentFloatVectorScorer [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [I] Parsing a regex with groups that may match empty strings seems to be incorrect sometimes [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [I] Parsing a regex with groups that may match empty strings seems to be incorrect sometimes [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [PR] Adds new simplified rescorer API to [Float|Byte]VectorValues [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
[I] Parsing a regex with groups that may match empty strings seems to be incorrect sometimes [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [PR] Help collectors take advantage of bulk-retrieval of doc values. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [I] switch website to new ASF logo [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [PR] Help collectors take advantage of bulk-retrieval of doc values. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
Re: [I] Declare MaxScoreAccumulator and DocScoreEncoder as public [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/12
[I] Test failure in TestFlatVectorScorer.testBulkScorerFloats [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
[PR] Help collectors take advantage of bulk-retrieval of doc values. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Use int-specific operations in PForUtil.encode() [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
[I] Declare MaxScoreAccumulator and DocScoreEncoder as public [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] chore: Seal BitSet to only allow FixedBitSet and SparseFixedBitSet [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Make calls to BM25Scorer#score inlinable. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Resolve some TODOs in TestGrouping [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Record FST ramBytesUsed correctly [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [I] Query parts ending with a colon are handled badly [LUCENE-373] [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Disabling point range collector if doc values not indexed [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Make `flatVectorsFormat` injectable in `Lucene99HnswVectorsFormat` to allow custom format and scorers [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Optimising findNextGEQ by making it branchless [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Optimising findNextGEQ by making it branchless [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [I] Query parts ending with a colon are handled badly [LUCENE-373] [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Bump block size of postings to 256. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Update code comment after bumping block size to 256. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] Fix encoding selection logic in Lucene104PostingsWriter [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
[PR] Update code comment after bumping block size to 256. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/11
Re: [PR] FirstPassGroupingCollector supports ignoring docs without group field [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] Refactor FirstPassGroupingCollector to improve readability. (#15136) [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] [QueryCache] Use RamUsageEstimator instead of defaulting to 1024 bytes for non-accountable query size [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] deps(java): bump org.apache.groovy:groovy-all from 4.0.28 to 5.0.0 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] Handle inconsistent schema on flush with index sorts [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] Adds new simplified rescorer API to [Float|Byte]VectorValues [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
[PR] Adds new simplified rescorer API to [Float|Byte]VectorValues [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] ci: bump actions/setup-java from 4.7.1 to 5.0.0 [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [I] CharTermAttributeImpl.java's termBuffer caused heap out of memory. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] optimise prefix sums in Lucene104PostingsReader [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] optimise prefix sums in Lucene104PostingsReader [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] Optimize a bit two more prefix sums. [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] Implement off-heap quantized scoring [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] Implement off-heap quantized scoring [lucene]
via GitHub
2025/09/10
Re: [PR] optimise prefix sums in Lucene104PostingsReader [lucene]
via GitHub
Earlier messages
Later messages