Agreed. I dislike overloaded TXT records. Proposed _w3addr as a prefix for namespacing purposes.
On Wed, Sep 18, 2024, 1:31 PM John Levine <[email protected]> wrote: > It appears that Dave Lawrence <[email protected]> said: > >Joe Abley writes: > >> > Would it be recommended to do a proposal that use either RRtype > >> > (TXT or WALLET) or choose one? > >> > >> I haven't read your proposal and don't have an opinion on that. I > >> agree that it sounds like a good question for you to ask yourself. > > > >You don't have an opinion on using TXT? > > Using TXT works pretty well so long as there's a _prefix tag in the > name. Overloading the main name leads to absurd results. > > R's, > John > > $ dig stanford.edu txt +dnssec > ;; Truncated, retrying in TCP mode. > > ; <<>> DiG 9.10.6 <<>> stanford.edu txt +dnssec > ;; global options: +cmd > ;; Got answer: > ;; ->>HEADER<<- opcode: QUERY, status: NOERROR, id: 50649 > ;; flags: qr rd ra ad; QUERY: 1, ANSWER: 64, AUTHORITY: 0, ADDITIONAL: 1 > > ;; OPT PSEUDOSECTION: > ; EDNS: version: 0, flags: do; udp: 1232 > ;; QUESTION SECTION: > ;stanford.edu. IN TXT > > ;; ANSWER SECTION: > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "Sendinblue-code:bde1f306529e82fd2ccf9857fc09aa98" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=8z0eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=fq1fb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=c00eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=nw5fb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=n4agb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "blitz=mu-0e24b17b-23dce65a-c0b14b75-e742cd66" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "e2ma-verification=fq1fb-remove" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "h1-domain-verification=aV4vQvSRHvQxGhvdz29L2ozsKDTReL7qKDgdjhPgzA5E7UC6" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=dy8eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "airtable-verification=13ac52fb202035dbad35b0ab24e598b4" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > > "pardot884873=1b7cebffc22a290049b6710c0620e741a3f4d3a720196287a95816f9afaa7695" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > > "stripe-verification=984c5a4eb98ae34bbaf60c12403c1d8889d4ad02b2dc672232a89b21f905bc20" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "brevo-code:09357c2630559d902817770f34dbf0b1" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=diffb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > > "wiz-domain-verification=2957e22f41cc73b19d44177ecf39bd1a1926a1e6362011b8f83e65aab5d6ef1a" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "google-site-verification=kyvps-t3mjXwz5HBQa7oO40qvObbV8z_B1IoySwe-GY" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > > "atlassian-domain-verification=C9ho3V/RWWifTCqh8sF3L0PI7jVZWAL9dCxVL1gzJvr6SYJCKBQ8nCX38z50vRQ6" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "google-site-verification=n-cl_O68vbC-_UmufTZMmLLQb9wKnuUo-4FPom4m3iA" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "google-site-verification=p4uNfSaD7rr13xbA1Q1yW6I0DckXOv1ujjc0FQGjGEM" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "mgverify=c7c142ba8b95199619ad561a75f165ad285c322b3892f9621c083b0293fd0da0" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=2i5eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=gu1ab" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "airtable-verification=b8f5e3c2468d582f896b4a8f0839dd8a" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=d1ueb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=4x8eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > > "bwZknJMLNV1XuaJAyUmKlAFrdZo+p5yDlTNACmDUWhgtyihfJc8oWMnK7hWLreN+ozU3mX91yHHzZx0adJPPPg==" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=a00eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=1qjbb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "airtable-verification=0a746053a028476f6d1671cbc9016585" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=7z0eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=2w2ab" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=7uqeb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=cvnbb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > > "adobe-idp-site-verification=4c872117a60d5c3b7d132914730b3f3e2189c67a217450a2f3bc18a683a98f78" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=b00eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=vnjbb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=q57fb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "google-site-verification=1HuKdQQTxv1R8v4dxihLzji-mH23d2KchIeaxsljN6Q" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=nbxfb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "google-site-verification=zwyVSZ2CSXXUndqTu5itEDFvp58bOFVBPAbtrIondBU" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=ey8eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "google-site-verification=bamHrkKBqpOQ8ouXQe0uFSuvVUFTB_TLju7gSCNq_Qw" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=7x8eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > > "htBOpqv5il135Xfa09GRiVHY09Xb9qXNj6o5lAfj8gNoBvyyGu5rSb4gvSj9lCUwY1NF0+wL2BO1ZDIcGIpADQ==" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "google-site-verification=C6QZVcR4K-mSTqLE_9uVC7twZdys_BRJLLVFwgGIG3E" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=4g5eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "v=spf1 ip4: > 171.67.219.64/27 ip4:171.67.224.0/28 ip4:171.67.43.137 ip4:171.67.43.138 > ip4:171.67.43.139 ip4:171.67.43.140 ip4:171.67.43.141 " "include:_ > spf.google.com include:_spf.qualtrics.com include:icpbounce.com include: > spf.protection.outlook.com ip4:1" "48.163.149.245 ip4:148.163.153.235 > ip4:148.163.135.119 ip4:148.163.139.119 ip4:67.231.149.169 > ip4:67.231.157.125 ip4:67.231.152.67 ip4:208.84.65.155 ?all" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=1u3eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "detectify-verification=bc8e96f8fbf64ced057d0f44eff83381" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=4pjbb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=8uqeb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "e2ma-verification=nbxfb-remove" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=k4dgb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=m0ggb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "SFMC-6lLIlwvbCaTM80Tq1R1zsnKi9CqM3R6ZPPvoE6sK" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "onetrust-domain-verification=1e6b4a2989b7412499dca24f8188396b" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=5g5eb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=6uqeb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "onetrust-domain-verification=2983144927f6450ea12b5557b2080dae" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > "amazonses:7IodrIPH40wdjQxliaAOOqSX8rn4q7lSiSvuFZPwUnY=" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT > > "pardot604641=4bbe27c356474886816017d9b5aea8f21f2d3c3b651096960379a441342c51fb" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN TXT "e2ma-verification=avqab" > stanford.edu. 1791 IN RRSIG TXT 13 2 1800 > 20241001145831 20240917140034 51348 stanford.edu. > 6mY7V6y3y/EWWuJ4tRDr8oGCdt8Tjm5hn1+s92P1WxCnp2JVErmNmAB6 > 52KxK1+3UyPFBhiLhoYpV1UwPAG13w== > > ;; Query time: 1 msec > ;; SERVER: 192.168.80.2#53(192.168.80.2) > ;; WHEN: Wed Sep 18 16:25:47 EDT 2024 > ;; MSG SIZE rcvd: 4053 > > _______________________________________________ > DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected] > To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] >
_______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
