-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 Mark,
On 2/13/19 06:46, bugzi...@apache.org wrote: > https://bz.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=63041 > > --- Comment #26 from Mark Thomas <ma...@apache.org> --- Got it. > > With the single & the pid of the process that is put in the > background is not the pid of the Tomcat process. If I specify > $CATALINA_PID and then configure systemd to use the same file with > PIDFILE everything starts working. > > That final "&" prevents the eval command being written to the > console when using catalina.sh start > > Assuming the above is correct I think we have two options: > > 1. Revert the "&" -> "&&" change. systemd users (and possibly > others) will be required to use a PID file and to tell systemd > where to find that file. > > 2. Revert both changes. systemd users will have to take no action. > Users wanting to redirect to a command will have to use a named > pipe. +1 on option 2 pid-files are anathema to systemd, so let's do them a favor. Also, logging huge amounts of data to an unrotatable file is something users have to swallow if they want to dump huge amounts of data to it. Finally, using a named-pipe is possible with the original startup script, so we aren't taking anything away from anyone. > I'm leaning towards 2 on the grounds this has the least impact on > the smallest number of users. This assumes that the number of > systemd users is greater than the number of users wanting to > redirect to a command. +1 - -chris -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - https://www.enigmail.net/ iQIzBAEBCAAdFiEEMmKgYcQvxMe7tcJcHPApP6U8pFgFAlxkKMIACgkQHPApP6U8 pFhRhxAAkOAiINas0qjNUFevzJOB3wVpiAjT4mJ338571582WazD7gLX66knDlRV UC1TXvENI/HADcpjgu2ncA7O8qHaEv3Sf5ZGN+JzYHfzVcwPBGq9P2N8WNZoFV6O qpYNfBj5Ph37ecxLzYYw0fCTVmNXoOpPqc+7c08VqxXSpJ89C0sYCbZhA1CKLJQr J3adJLrVdUOJSGBMEJaYzdKH6kWHVwZSohq5qsqfJrgfKkaSn8f/usq6Qdzawnd5 RDIzNYvPAkfid9VleS43kVhiKAR5+xhQMUkygVWQxCrnOdciI3UFrVUGaxHb843r j0NnLneqAqcQC6ECR/bX087tSU/XpVd3BvS7H/DSxGnd/fZFL2yhV29nE9iMBKOj YjOKRdVCXZJRbf+OqweMM7GpSYdBd3AHNqtfilAR5id9PbxhwoJzBd6Ebck+mw05 jmDsNirX6PFSoaC6+bnlAsdlcMGNtBj4h84SA65jtNhdSJPymC+osbaM6Or8VeIi EHbLWusYK7JWrBP7myQzLYfiXNw2Fa6G3pfTBCt8B+VI2FW37692d3qFwWjY2ZDj 84yoPNreli1Pgud6bzc5eqwGkWwdDuYLnzKAUK1EQ3h3G4lhZvZiVrD/bQCqo64f q8tQpyXBQPcX13252ZjTHF6FXJ+inE5XMS7to1T/U+YLnf/oeCk= =M6xb -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@tomcat.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@tomcat.apache.org
