Re: Projects incubating for a long time

2025-03-20 Thread Paul King
A day earlier, I sent a different but related suggestion to NLPCraft (with my mentor hat on). I'll make sure feedback gets back to this list if they respond to that suggestion. Cheers, Paul. On Fri, Mar 21, 2025 at 8:55 AM Justin Mclean wrote: > > Hi, > > Yesterday, I went over the projects that

Projects incubating for a long time

2025-03-20 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Yesterday, I went over the projects that have been in the incubator for too long to see where they were. I’ve sent them an email to focus on graduation or retirement. Here’s the list: Toree 2015 Annotator 2016 - last report suggests they will retire Livy 2017 Nemo 2018 - discussing possibl

Re: What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread Dave Fisher
> On Mar 20, 2025, at 8:52 AM, sebb wrote: > > On Thu, 20 Mar 2025 at 15:39, tison wrote: >> >>> The source for lists.apache.org belongs to the vendor and I believe that >>> the PonyMail Podling’s source is a fork that differs and lacks proprietary >>> parts > > AIUI, lists.a.o runs code

Re: What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread Dave Fisher
> On Mar 20, 2025, at 12:44 AM, Xuanwo wrote: > > It looks like PonyMail has been discontinued. How about we retire PonyMail > and switch to more mature solutions like Mailman and HyperKitty? lists.apache.org is a provided service from a vendor with a contract from the ASF. This Pony Mail di

Re: What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread tison
> The source for lists.apache.org belongs to the vendor and I believe that the > PonyMail Podling’s source is a fork that differs and lacks proprietary parts Thanks for your information. If so, I agree that we may retire the project if the current PMC won't continue it. My personal feeling is tha

Re: What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread Dave Fisher
Hi Tison, > On Mar 20, 2025, at 8:23 AM, tison wrote: > > Hi Dave, > > On Retirement, I have one question: does PonyMail have no more efforts > needed, even regular maintenance? The source for lists.apache.org belongs to the vendor and I believe that the PonyMail Podling’s source is a fork wh

Re: What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread tison
Hi Dave, On Retirement, I have one question: does PonyMail have no more efforts needed, even regular maintenance? BTW, we have some repo that are part of our infrastructure, they don't do ASF "release" IIUC but also not "retire" or archive. Best, tison. Dave Fisher 于2025年3月20日周四 23:20写道: > > L

Re: What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread Dave Fisher
Let’s focus on the original question. > On Mar 20, 2025, at 12:35 AM, Justin Mclean wrote: > > Hi, > > The Pony Mail project has been incubating since 2016 and lately has failed to > submit its reports. The PPMC is struggling to attract people and only has two > or three active people on it.

Re: What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread sebb
On Thu, 20 Mar 2025 at 11:58, Shane Curcuru wrote: > > tison wrote on 3/20/25 3:53 AM: > >> HyperKitty looks much nicer than PonyMail and is well-maintained. > > > > Not sure if we should fork a new thread to discuss about choosing > > mailing list archive. > > Yes, discussions around mail archivi

Re: What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread tison
> HyperKitty looks much nicer than PonyMail and is well-maintained. Not sure if we should fork a new thread to discuss about choosing mailing list archive. Currently, on our website [1] we advocate three options: 1. [Apache mail archives](https://lists.apache.org/) 2. [MARC](http://marc.info/) 3

Re: What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread Xuanwo
It looks like PonyMail has been discontinued. How about we retire PonyMail and switch to more mature solutions like Mailman and HyperKitty? HyperKitty looks much nicer than PonyMail and is well-maintained. Here is an example from Fedora: https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/ On Thu, Mar 20,

What to do with Pony Mail?

2025-03-20 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, The Pony Mail project has been incubating since 2016 and lately has failed to submit its reports. The PPMC is struggling to attract people and only has two or three active people on it. We have discussed this project before but haven't concluded what to do with it. It is a mature project th