Re: Just want to highlight a PR on simplifying asserts

2022-10-18 Thread Houston Putman
Agreed. I think this is good stuff, there are a lot of bad asserts in our tests, and this will only help make debugging easier. I'm going to try my best to get through the PR over the next few days. - Houston On Tue, Oct 18, 2022 at 12:50 PM Jan Høydahl wrote: > +1 > > If it gets merged both t

Re: Just want to highlight a PR on simplifying asserts

2022-10-18 Thread Jan Høydahl
+1 If it gets merged both to main and branch_9x it will not cause backport pain at all for 95% of the PRs. Kudos for caring for the "boring" parts of open source! Jan > 18. okt. 2022 kl. 15:35 skrev Eric Pugh : > > Hi all, > > I started, and Kevin pushed to completion > https://issues.apache

Re: Just want to highlight a PR on simplifying asserts

2022-10-18 Thread Kevin Risden
Changeset size is ~300 files - much smaller than the thousands of files touched by spotless. The tangible benefits being that error messages are no longer "assertion failed" but instead say what was different in the case of arrays the two arrays or in the case of some equals the two values. This i

Re: Just want to highlight a PR on simplifying asserts

2022-10-18 Thread Ishan Chattopadhyaya
I agree that these changes are good for the codebase. But, I am very much disturbed by the changeset size. It will make backporting, working on existing changes etc. a massive pain. I don't see the benefit enough to outweigh the massive loss in productivity. Solr needs improvement in efficiency, pe

Just want to highlight a PR on simplifying asserts

2022-10-18 Thread Eric Pugh
Hi all, I started, and Kevin pushed to completion https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-16311, which is to simplify our assert logic. It touches 330 files, all various tests…. I think it’s a great enhancement, but before clicking merge, wanted to give a chance for someone to speak up o