Re: solr query alerting

2024-04-30 Thread Luke Kot-Zaniewski (BLOOMBERG/ 919 3RD A)
I love the name "luwak"! I was about to suggest the same but was worried about the trademark concerns and I assumed there was a reason they changed the name when donating it to lucene. From: dev@solr.apache.org At: 04/30/24 15:56:22 UTC-4:00To: dev@solr.apache.org Subject: Re: solr query alerti

Re: solr query alerting

2024-04-30 Thread Luke Kot-Zaniewski (BLOOMBERG/ 919 3RD A)
The point about maintenance is obviously important. I understand how a contribution by a (relatively) new community member always carries extra abandonment risk. Regarding the naming, I like inverted-search over indexed-queries because indexing the queries is just a part of the feature (albeit

Re: solr query alerting

2024-04-30 Thread Jan Høydahl
Luwak is the original name of the Lucene monitor, contributed by Flax back in the days: https://github.com/flaxsearch/luwak Perhaps we could go full circle (if no trademark issues) to call it the Solr luwak module? Luwak is a type of coffee, and thus related to percolator 😉 Otherwise “stored-qu

Re: Failed startup behavior

2024-04-30 Thread Gus Heck
I would be surprised if my refactor caused a change in this behavior. All I did was move some initialization out into a ServeletContextListener. If I did cause such a change, that would be unintended. >From the perspective of a web application container (which is what Jetty is). There's no reason

Re: Issue with marking replicas down at startup

2024-04-30 Thread Houston Putman
I've created a PR to address this: https://github.com/apache/solr/pull/2432 Open to other ways of approaching it though. - Houston On Tue, Apr 30, 2024 at 4:44 AM Mark Miller wrote: > There is a publish node as down and wait method that just waits until then > down states show up in the cluste

Failed startup behavior

2024-04-30 Thread David Smiley
I noticed (as well as my colleague Vincent and with more detail and root causing) that if Solr's CoreContainer has some issue starting up for almost any reason, that it only logs an error (in SolrDispatchFilter). From Jetty’s perspective, startup has succeeded, thus the server is running. Seeing

Re: solr query alerting

2024-04-30 Thread David Smiley
I agree the feature is relevant / useful. Another angle on the module vs sandbox or wherever else is maintenance cost. If a lot of code is being contributed as is here, then as a PMC member I hope to get a subjective sense that folks are interested in maintaining it. On one hand we have a number

Re: solr query alerting

2024-04-30 Thread Luke Kot-Zaniewski (BLOOMBERG/ 919 3RD A)
Hi All, I wanted to bump this and share this recent blog post about netflix using elastic's percolator for reverse search https://netflixtechblog.com/reverse-searching-netflixs-federated-graph-222ac5d23576 to highlight this feature's relevance into 2024 (even if it isn't the highest priority).

Re: SolrJ HTTP SolrClient class hierarchy

2024-04-30 Thread Eric Pugh
That makes sense. It might be interesting at our next community meet up to bring up some of these “umbrella” tickets and socialize them around, to activate some folks! > On Apr 30, 2024, at 9:21 AM, Jan Høydahl wrote: > > There is an umbrella issue for major SolrJ changes > https://issues.ap

Re: SolrJ HTTP SolrClient class hierarchy

2024-04-30 Thread Jan Høydahl
There is an umbrella issue for major SolrJ changes https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-15730. Some of the sub tasks are 10.0 only. Could add a rename jira there? Jan > 30. apr. 2024 kl. 15:04 skrev Eric Pugh : > > Please! It would be nice if someone laid out the work to be done in som

Re: SolrJ HTTP SolrClient class hierarchy

2024-04-30 Thread Eric Pugh
Please! It would be nice if someone laid out the work to be done in some tickets so folks could pick it up…. Otherwise it looks a bit daunting! > On Apr 30, 2024, at 7:38 AM, Jan Høydahl wrote: > > In Solr 10, SolrJ will have new maven coordinates and the need to explicitly > pull in solrj-

Re: SolrJ HTTP SolrClient class hierarchy

2024-04-30 Thread Jan Høydahl
In Solr 10, SolrJ will have new maven coordinates and the need to explicitly pull in solrj-xx dependencies. So we coult also do a few key renames such as "Http2SolrClient" -> "HttpJettySolrClient", while we're busy breaking things :) Jan > 30. apr. 2024 kl. 13:21 skrev Jason Gerlowski : > > Th

Re: SolrJ HTTP SolrClient class hierarchy

2024-04-30 Thread Jason Gerlowski
Thanks for summarizing this all David! We have HttpSolrClientBase AND BaseHttpSolrClient?! A bit of the messiness here seems like it will resolve itself "automatically" if we make good on removing the existing deprecations. (Though given how "entrenched" the Apache client is, that will require a

Re: Issue with marking replicas down at startup

2024-04-30 Thread Mark Miller
There is a publish node as down and wait method that just waits until then down states show up in the cluster state. But waiting won't do any good until down is actually published and it still is not. I'm pretty down has never been published on startup despite appearances. I've seen two ramificatio