Re: [Vote] New committers

2006-06-18 Thread Guido Casper
Joerg Heinicke schrieb: I'd like to introduce some people of our community and invite them for becoming committers of the Cocoon project. 1. Andreas Hochsteger +1 2. Peter Hunsberger +1 3. Jason Johnston +1 Guido

Re: [vote] Simone Gianni as a new Cocoon committer

2006-03-26 Thread Guido Casper
Sylvain Wallez schrieb: I'd like to propose Simone Gianni for Cocoon committership. +1 Guido

Re: [vote] Niclas Hedhman as a new Cocoon committer

2006-03-26 Thread Guido Casper
Daniel Fagerstrom schrieb: I'd like to propose Niclas Hedhman as a new Cocoon committer. +1 Guido

Re: [RT][long] Cocoon 3.0: the necessary mutation

2005-12-04 Thread Guido Casper
ite. Although I have the slight feeling that such a discussion may be doomed to lead to nowhere I thought the subject of Cocoon 3.0 would justify it. I hope you agree and bare with me :-) Guido -- Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards Guido Casper S&N AG Competence Center Open Source Klingenderstr. 5 D 33100 Paderborn voice +49 5251/1581-87 fax+49 5251/1581-71 eMail [EMAIL PROTECTED] Webhttp://www.s-und-n.de

Re: [vote] Arje Cahn as a new Cocoon committer

2005-09-10 Thread Guido Casper
Sylvain Wallez wrote: I'd like to be the voice of a general opinion among Cocoon developers that Arjé Cahn should be made a Cocoon committer. +1 Guido

Re: [VOTE] Jorg Heymans as new committer

2005-08-01 Thread Guido Casper
Antonio Gallardo wrote: So, I'm pleased to propose Jorg Heymans, as a committer. +1 Guido

Re: DirectoryGenerator using abstract Source

2005-07-20 Thread Guido Casper
omewhat stalled. I'm myself guilty of one of those and if I don't find time to continue to work on it RSN I'll go for removing that one from SVN to reduce confusion. Guido -- Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards Guido Casper S&N AG Competence Center Open Source Klingenderst

Re: [vote] splitting cocoon.xconf

2004-12-21 Thread Guido Casper
Sylvain Wallez wrote: Please cast your votes. +1 Guido

Re: [Vote] Component confs per sitemap [was: [RT]]

2004-12-20 Thread Guido Casper
Carsten Ziegeler wrote: So, please cast your votes! +1 Guido

Re: Client side validation

2004-11-24 Thread Guido Casper
Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: This may be a little off topic and I'm asking out of curiosity what others think. But I wonder if flow (and continuations in particular) and cforms really is an appropriate technology for "rich" (and potentially stateful) clients? It's hard to say without having a con

Re: Client side validation

2004-11-24 Thread Guido Casper
Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 23 nov. 04, à 10:53, oceatoon a écrit : ...Is different JS really coded for different browsers? I thought there were only those with JS and those without, in the second case validation would go back to Server Side but no different version of scripts... your (future)

Re: [VOTE] Release of 2.1.6

2004-11-18 Thread Guido Casper
Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 18 nov. 04, à 00:43, Ugo Cei a écrit : hmm.. are you testing on macosx and seeing this sometimes only? No, on Linux. And it seems to be repeatable. You're right, sorry. I see the same here on macosx ad webdav-step3.xml:93. Works here (WinXP). Hmm, really strange (gi

Re: [VOTE] Leszek Gawron and Ralph Goers as committers

2004-10-28 Thread Guido Casper
Torsten Curdt wrote: Folks please cast your votes for: [ ] Leszek [ ] Ralph as Apache Cocoon committers. +1 for both. Guido

Re: [RT] Some notes about the "Real Blocks" issue

2004-10-17 Thread Guido Casper
Ralph Goers wrote: In short, the fact that Cocoon is just a bunch of parts that get configured is one of Cocoon's major strengths. However, the current configuration is pretty easy to understand and modify. If the replacement container makes the configuration more complex and less understanda

Re: [RT] Some notes about the "Real Blocks" issue

2004-10-17 Thread Guido Casper
Sorry, I thought what's being discussed is wether or not to use Spring as an intra-block container and that Tani as inter-block container is set. Am I wrong? Guido

Re: [RT] Some notes about the "Real Blocks" issue

2004-10-16 Thread Guido Casper
Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: The point that I was trying to make is that I really like the idea of considering the "cocoon core" container separately from the "cocoon applications" one, as much for marketing reasons as for technical ones. I too like the idea. Guido

Re: [RT] Some notes about the "Real Blocks" issue

2004-10-16 Thread Guido Casper
Guido Casper wrote: Don't you like Spring's way of DI? Sorry Bertrand, ignore that, of course you already told you like it. May mail wasn't (only) addressed at you :-) Guido

Re: [RT] Some notes about the "Real Blocks" issue

2004-10-16 Thread Guido Casper
Bertrand Delacretaz wrote: Le 16 oct. 04, à 11:14, Guido Casper a écrit : ...for a start it would be the easiest to just drop in spring-core.jar. But we would have to make sure, that this cannot be interpreted as an invitation to introduce other dependencies Dependencies on Spring in the

Re: [RT] Some notes about the "Real Blocks" issue

2004-10-16 Thread Guido Casper
Ugo, can you explain what exactly are the dependencies on Spring? My rather limited) understanding is, that we primarily would use Spring's BeanFactory. As the BeanFactory is: a) designed to not introduce any dependency for your components b) rather trivial to re-implement for a start it would b

Re: svn commit: rev 54018 - cocoon/whiteboard/butterfly/lib

2004-10-08 Thread Guido Casper
Ugo Cei wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Added: cocoon/whiteboard/butterfly/lib/js-1.6R1pre.jar (contents, props changed) Log: Added Rhino jar Ugo, what does Spring use that for? Do you have any pointers? Spring 1.2 will have the possibility of managing not just regular Java beans, but also

Re: svn commit: rev 54018 - cocoon/whiteboard/butterfly/lib

2004-10-07 Thread Guido Casper
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Author: ugo Date: Thu Oct 7 14:15:48 2004 New Revision: 54018 Added: cocoon/whiteboard/butterfly/lib/js-1.6R1pre.jar (contents, props changed) Log: Added Rhino jar Ugo, what does Spring use that for? Do you have any pointers? Thanks Guido

Re: xmldb site is down?

2004-09-11 Thread Guido Casper
intained? Thanks for your help. Guido Antonio Gallardo wrote: Guido Casper dijo: Antonio Gallardo wrote: Hi, while cheking for some updates, I found that the xmldb site is down: http://www.xmldb.org/ Can someone tell where is the site now? http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=xindice-users&m=1086542

Re: xmldb site is down?

2004-09-08 Thread Guido Casper
Antonio Gallardo wrote: Hi, while cheking for some updates, I found that the xmldb site is down: http://www.xmldb.org/ Can someone tell where is the site now? http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=xindice-users&m=108654200411626&w=2 Guido

Re: [RT] Concerns surrounding CocoonNG

2004-08-10 Thread Guido Casper
Niclas Hedhman wrote: Looking at the actual differences; public AbcComponent( org.hedhman.niclas.SomeDependency some ) { m_SomeDependency = some; } /** @avalon.dependency type="org.hedhman.niclas.SomeDependency" * key = "some" */ public void service(ServiceManager man ) { m_SomeDepend

Re: [RT] A Groovy Kind of Sitemap

2004-07-28 Thread Guido Casper
Leszek Gawron wrote: Guido Casper wrote: One thing to keep in mind is that the sitemap is a declarative thing (and the pointy brackets always remind us of that). While skripting the I think this is not true. For those who do not use flowscript sitemap became a "programming language&qu

Re: [RT] A Groovy Kind of Sitemap

2004-07-28 Thread Guido Casper
First let me say that I'm really excited by your work. Thanks for that! Ugo Cei wrote: Il giorno 28/lug/04, alle 04:02, Vadim Gritsenko ha scritto: Why stop half way and live with one more interpreter's penalty? Convert straight to Java - works faster and less memory consumption! And we are back o

Re: [Vote] Marking internal classes

2004-07-19 Thread Guido Casper
Reinhard Poetz wrote: Unico Hommes wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Sorry, I think I was not clear (my fault). I intended the vote to be about marking (like within javadocs) either: -internal classes or (the opposite): -published classes The first is what Vadim suggested and most simple to do (there

Re: [Vote] Marking internal classes

2004-07-18 Thread Guido Casper
Unico Hommes wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Vadim Gritsenko wrote: In all other situations, Carsten is right - this might cause backward incompatibility. This is important for user-facing classes. Should we start marking classes as internal, like "INTERNAL!!!" in javad

[Vote] Marking internal classes

2004-07-18 Thread Guido Casper
Guido Casper wrote: Vadim Gritsenko wrote: In all other situations, Carsten is right - this might cause backward incompatibility. This is important for user-facing classes. Should we start marking classes as internal, like "INTERNAL!!!" in javadoc or some such? What about i

Re: Clean up exception not throwed in some methods over the code.

2004-07-12 Thread Guido Casper
Vadim Gritsenko wrote: In all other situations, Carsten is right - this might cause backward incompatibility. This is important for user-facing classes. Should we start marking classes as internal, like "INTERNAL!!!" in javadoc or some such? What about introducing @cocoon.usage tags I proposed a

Re: Playing with the JCR RI

2004-06-24 Thread Guido Casper
Ugo Cei wrote: Dear Cocooners, I've just started to take a look at the JCR (a.k.a. JSR-170) Reference Implementation from Slide, after having read the latest JSR draft, and I feel like exploring the possibilities of its usage inside Cocoon. First thing I tried to do is an implementation of the

Re: Javadocs for published classes/interfaces

2004-05-27 Thread Guido Casper
Carsten Ziegeler wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Does anyone (besides me) think the distinction between published and non-published classes/interfaces is a useful thing? IMO it's a pity that the Java language doesn't provide any means for that. Yes, makes sense to me. Could we add the ta

Re: Javadocs for published classes/interfaces

2004-05-26 Thread Guido Casper
think the distinction between published and non-published classes/interfaces is a useful thing? IMO it's a pity that the Java language doesn't provide any means for that. Is there a better way/format for generating docs for that? Guido Carsten -Original Message- From: Guido Casper

Javadocs for published classes/interfaces

2004-05-25 Thread Guido Casper
. So I decided to base the task (mostly taken from the QDoxSource currently) on QDox, being already part of the build and tools/lib anyway (but I'm open to suggestions). WDYT? Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open

Re: Status of repository block and webdav question.

2004-05-19 Thread Guido Casper
Rolf Kulemann wrote: On Wed, 2004-05-19 at 09:10, Guido Casper wrote: Rolf Kulemann wrote: What u mean with Repository block? IMHO there are currently two approaches hosted within the repository bloch, which should be divided normally. 1.) SourceRepository which acts on various interfaces like

Re: Status of repository block and webdav question.

2004-05-19 Thread Guido Casper
implementation which is too flow oriented (no exception handling etc.) These 2 (interfaces) are not all that different (like different approaches) and I plan to merge them. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open So

Re: Status of repository block and webdav question.

2004-05-18 Thread Guido Casper
understands the implications of taking one block or the other... And my last question: .what version of Slide is currently integrated in Cocoon? 2.0 Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-

Re: [RT] Generating docs and entries for sitemap component from JavaDocs

2004-04-29 Thread Guido Casper
that component (and added to the index etc.) +1 for both. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn http://www.s-und-n.de -

Re: [RT] Use of flowscript or the pyramid of contracts

2004-04-28 Thread Guido Casper
Stefano Mazzocchi wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Once such a customized doclet mechanism is in-place (Does someone know wether QDox already has an Ant task? Or maybe we should use XDoclet for that?) it may easily be extended for "some kind of" flowscript-API. are you volunteering? ;-)

Re: [RT] Use of flowscript or the pyramid of contracts

2004-04-23 Thread Guido Casper
Stefano Mazzocchi wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Yes, I realized that flowscript is the perfect solution to the missing piece of the pyramid of contracts for the webapp space. I just feel we should much more leverage it for this role and it is vital to give more emphasis to the user. I'm

Re: [RT] Use of flowscript or the pyramid of contracts (was Re: [RT] Checked exceptions considered harmful)

2004-04-20 Thread Guido Casper
Leon Widdershoven wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Yes that might be one reason. Another one IMO is that it's much easier to (conceptually) come up with a reusable sitemap component (being a specialized thing) than it is to come up with a reusable flow component. Guido I think that is the

Re: Modular database component

2004-04-20 Thread Guido Casper
something more "flowscript-supportive". Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn http://www.s-und-n.de -

Re: Modular database component

2004-04-20 Thread Guido Casper
rations too. The question is whether we don't duplicate the efforts of e.g. OJB with this approach? The only difference is that you don't need Java objects ... Best Regards, Antonio Gallardo -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Cente

Re: [RT] Use of flowscript or the pyramid of contracts (was Re: [RT] Checked exceptions considered harmful)

2004-04-19 Thread Guido Casper
systems to enforce your latest notion of best practices. Tim, don't take the word for everything said in a RT thread and don't worry that access to Java will be disabled in the 2.x branch (if ever) as this certainly would break any production system running on with flow. Gu

Re: [RT] Use of flowscript or the pyramid of contracts (was Re: [RT] Checked exceptions considered harmful)

2004-04-19 Thread Guido Casper
Hunsberger, Peter wrote: Guido Casper <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: As I alway try to keep my flowscript as "exception-handling-free" as possible and as I feel that this sentiment is not shared by everyone, I thought it is a good oportunity to come up with another concern.

Re: [RT] Use of flowscript or the pyramid of contracts

2004-04-18 Thread Guido Casper
Antonio Gallardo wrote: Guido Casper dijo: I think that cocoon.getComponent(role) would be enough if writing those components would be as painless as writing flowscript. No need for more complex stuff. I don't think developers aren't eager to write reusable components. But currently

Re: [RT] Use of flowscript or the pyramid of contracts (was Re: [RT] Checked exceptions considered harmful)

2004-04-18 Thread Guido Casper
rfect solution to the missing piece of the pyramid of contracts for the webapp space. I just feel we should much more leverage it for this role and it is vital to give more emphasis to the user. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn http://www.s-und-n.de -

[RT] Use of flowscript or the pyramid of contracts (was Re: [RT] Checked exceptions considered harmful)

2004-04-17 Thread Guido Casper
ch should always be high level and easy to be used by users) and provide some kind of doclet mechanism that generates the docs for our "official" flowscript API. The reason I'm thinking about this is that I wondered wether the repository block justifies its existence now that we are s

Re: [VOTE] Make ProcessingException extend CascadingRuntimeException

2004-04-17 Thread Guido Casper
Ugo Cei wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Ugo Cei wrote: WebDAVRepository.java (swallowed): } catch (ProcessingException pe) { this.getLogger().error("Error saving dom to: " + this.repoBaseUrl + uri, pe); } WebDAVRepositoryPropertyHelper.java (swallowed): } catch (ProcessingEx

Re: [VOTE] Make ProcessingException extend CascadingRuntimeException

2004-04-16 Thread Guido Casper
ror("Error serializing node " + value, pe); } Ehm, I didn't follow all the discussions very closely, but if you want to remove something please be aware that these Exceptions are not just swallowed (don't know about the others) since after the catch clause follows a "re

Re: [RT] Future of the Slide Source

2004-04-14 Thread Guido Casper
Stephan Michels wrote: The current webdav methods are: ... SUBSCRIBE UNSUBSCRIBE POLL EVENT TRANSACTION ... Where do these come from? They are not webdav methods. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open So

Re: [RT] Future of the Slide Source

2004-04-14 Thread Guido Casper
Stephan Michels wrote: Am Mi, den 14.04.2004 schrieb Guido Casper um 9:08: Stephan Michels wrote: The Repository IFs seems be more helper classes than components. And I think we should using the Source objects instead to reflect all aspects like locking, property handling etc. Care to elaborate

Re: [RT] Future of the Slide Source

2004-04-14 Thread Guido Casper
Sources (which BTW is their original intention) and modifying operation via Repository - quite useful. However I use flowscript (which I suspect you don't like :-) for that. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Op

Re: Repository support for property queries (DASL?)

2004-04-14 Thread Guido Casper
IIUC). So what you might want to do is to create a DASL searcher (like the DASLTransformer?). Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-3

Re: Repository support for property queries (DASL?)

2004-04-13 Thread Guido Casper
one and only interface to repositories (of all sizes and needs) then this particular component may be mostly redundant as having a portability layer becomes pointless. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source

Re: [New Repository] Major design issue concerning state

2004-04-09 Thread Guido Casper
The way WebDAV is designed (and the way lock tokens work) allows both "session-internal-only" locking behaviour or "user-centric" locking behaviour. The difficulties in managing locking state are due to the way WebdavResource works. http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=slide-dev&m=108057214410350&w=

Re: [RT] RepositorySource

2004-04-09 Thread Guido Casper
Stephan Michels wrote: Am Do, den 08.04.2004 schrieb Guido Casper um 20:18: Stephan Michels wrote: What the status of the WebDAVSource? It seems that it doesn't implement any versioning. Or am I wrong? No. I (vaguely) remember some discussion considering your VersionableSource vs. Sylv

Re: [RT] RepositorySource

2004-04-08 Thread Guido Casper
Stephan Michels wrote: Am Do, den 08.04.2004 schrieb Guido Casper um 17:08: Rolf Kulemann wrote: Looking at the repository block, one will see that there is already a RepositorySource, but that source and the RepositorySourceFactory are not meant to be used with the new Repository interface from

Re: RepsitoryPropertyHelper.getProperty(depth)?

2004-04-08 Thread Guido Casper
s say "all child nodes" of a collection/node using the repository interface? Or is it a concern of a RepositorySource? No, some mechanism to retrieve collection members (getChildren() or getMembers()) would be a welcome addition to the Repository interface IMO. Gu

Re: [RT] RepositorySource

2004-04-08 Thread Guido Casper
Rolf Kulemann wrote: Looking at the repository block, one will see that there is already a RepositorySource, but that source and the RepositorySourceFactory are not meant to be used with the new Repository interface from Guido. What I have in mind is: A new RepositorySourceFactory should simply lo

Re: [PROP] Repository interface

2004-04-05 Thread Guido Casper
Rolf Kulemann wrote: On Mon, 2004-04-05 at 13:38, Guido Casper wrote: Rolf Kulemann wrote: [Related to http://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=28189] As for WebDAVRepsoitoryVersioningHelper.setVersioned(): I don't think it is a good idea to throw an UnsupportedOperationExce

Re: [PROP] Repository interface

2004-04-05 Thread Guido Casper
implemented by: -copy to a temporary resource -check wether the temporary resource is version-controlled -move the temporary resource back overriding the original resource We also need to set appropriate locks if supported, imho. Yes. Guido -- Guido Casper

Re: [PROP] Repository interface

2004-04-05 Thread Guido Casper
Rolf Kulemann wrote: On Mon, 2004-04-05 at 13:38, Guido Casper wrote: Rolf Kulemann wrote: I just changed the code a little bit. However it's now a little hacky and needs completion as after the copy you should check wether the destination is version controlled and if that's the cas

Re: [PROP] Repository interface

2004-04-05 Thread Guido Casper
's the case undo the move (to keep the old version history) and return false. I don't know the details of how to check wether a resource is under version control right now (would have to check the DeltaV spec). Guido -- Guido Casper - S&

Re: Problem creating (WebDAV) resources with new repository interface

2004-04-04 Thread Guido Casper
Rolf Kulemann wrote: On Sun, 2004-04-04 at 17:00, Guido Casper wrote: Rolf Kulemann wrote: Hello (Guido), I have done a small js file to test the functionalities of the new WebDAVRepository[1] using the NEW Repository[2] interface. I encountered a problem creating new reosurces. It does not

Re: Problem creating (WebDAV) resources with new repository interface

2004-04-04 Thread Guido Casper
, boolean create) etc. Makes sense? Or have I missed a way to create a new resource? -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn

Moving FlowXXXModules out of scratchpad

2004-04-03 Thread Guido Casper
Is everybody fine with moving FlowAttributeModule and FlowContinuationModule from scratchpad to core? Is a vote needed? I guess no. If noone objects I go ahead tomorrow. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open So

Re: Repository

2004-04-02 Thread Guido Casper
. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn http://www.s-und-n.de -

Re: Repository

2004-04-02 Thread Guido Casper
Rolf Kulemann wrote: On Fri, 2004-04-02 at 11:40, Guido Casper wrote: -link management What do u mean? I thin forrests LinkRewriter is doing a fine job. Please explain your idea in more detail. I'm thinking of managing linking information within metadata/properties in a bidirectional w

Re: Repository

2004-04-02 Thread Guido Casper
Rolf Kulemann wrote: On Fri, 2004-04-02 at 08:34, Guido Casper wrote: On top of this other higher level components might be build. Among the things I have in mind are: -a document store accommodating a certain array of use cases and being simple to use from the flow layer (in fact there might be

Repository (was Re: Linotype)

2004-04-01 Thread Guido Casper
Rolf Kulemann wrote: On Sat, 2004-03-27 at 16:31, Guido Casper wrote: Concerning the repository ... I just committed another repository interface :-) that tries to be a best effort in consolidating all the different approaches and accommodating all concerns in a flexible way (by having opional

Re: Linotype

2004-03-27 Thread Guido Casper
Ugo Cei wrote: Fellow Cocooners, after having neglected my weblog for a long time, I'm starting to feel the urge to blog again, but I want to use a better software than the homegrown thing I was using before. So I started looking into Linotype again and decided that it is in need of quite a lar

Re: WebDAV status in cocoon

2004-03-17 Thread Guido Casper
ly continues to do so), gathering experience with it and helping testing and further stabilizing is not the worst thing to do IMO :-) Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-

Re: Response to workflow

2004-03-17 Thread Guido Casper
w long until Andreas returns from vacation? :-) Michi -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn http://www.s-und-n.de -

Re: Response to workflow

2004-03-16 Thread Guido Casper
keep going forever ;-) The existing code base might not satisfy everybody, but at least it's something concrete to start with, even if it will be totally modified resp. refactored in the end. Michi -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competen

Re: Response to workflow

2004-03-16 Thread Guido Casper
d on a standard is too ambitious. Leaving out some more complex constructs decreases usability. It might be an option to choose a (proper) subset of a standard with which a large percentage (definitely more than 80%. Having to resort to another solution in one of four situations is not accepta

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-16 Thread Guido Casper
PI, but like I said previously, having done so, be prepared to throw it out Yes. I take that as a precondition for any scratchpad code (if not for any code within the Cocoon CVS). However there doesn't seem to be much interest in that code anyway. So I rather wait for other s

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-15 Thread Guido Casper
e. Then maybe this would give us probably the remaining 20% for those who need the whole thing? Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn http://www.s-und-n.de -

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-15 Thread Guido Casper
Hunsberger, Peter wrote: Guido Casper <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: Hunsberger, Peter wrote: Guido Casper <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: Hunsberger, Peter wrote: However, on the Cocoon side it's not the GUI I'm worried about, it's the underlying engine. There may s

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-13 Thread Guido Casper
Hunsberger, Peter wrote: Guido Casper <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: Hunsberger, Peter wrote: However, on the Cocoon side it's not the GUI I'm worried about, it's the underlying engine. There may still be value in one of the other projects, but I'm personally after v

Re: Responses to workflow experiences

2004-03-13 Thread Guido Casper
people on this list being able to integrate Rhino equally easily), just want to show how flexible the state pattern is. And basically that's a major point, it gives you a very flexible approach while allowing you to continue working with what you are already familiar with. WDYT? Guido

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-09 Thread Guido Casper
tting how that might work :-) Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn http://www.s-und-n.de -

Re: form framework clean up

2004-03-09 Thread Guido Casper
Torsten Curdt wrote: Since we are currently in the middle of cleaning up and focussing on *the* one form framework I like to propose and get rid of precept. *snief* I guess it's more or less dead code now and it's an unecessary choice we should get rid of IMO. I doubt anyone is using it so we won

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-09 Thread Guido Casper
Hunsberger, Peter wrote: You can call it whatever you want but a "state" in a FSM and a "continuation" in a script are exactly the same thing, they need to contain the same amount of data to be able to resort the execution. The problems in replicating one across containers will be the same prob

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-09 Thread Guido Casper
Hunsberger, Peter wrote: A good implementation of work flow handling for Cocoon could be the most important piece of missing capability that can be added. For the most part good work flow engines are expensive proprietary pieces of software. If a generalized, open source, document handling framew

Re: [CocoonForms] END of code freeze

2004-03-09 Thread Guido Casper
Torsten Curdt wrote: Shouldn't one be able to keep the old block and use 2.1.5-dev? ...as an interim solution? Yes, I can live with that. But I think it's not a good sign for our users. A user should have a chance to migrate while using a released version. Guido

Re: [CocoonForms] END of code freeze

2004-03-09 Thread Guido Casper
Vadim Gritsenko wrote: Sylvain Wallez wrote: Reinhard Pötz wrote: ... Sorry for this. I thought there was no need for the old block but if somebody needs it we can revert the removal. Oh yes, *please*, *please*, because this instantly breaks all applications that use woody and the latest C

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-08 Thread Guido Casper
Hunsberger, Peter wrote: Guido Casper <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: Hunsberger, Peter wrote: For the end user I believe you always have to have modeling tools for building work flow, the internal implementation should be completely transparent; the first time I wrote GUI modeling too

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-08 Thread Guido Casper
tool being both. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn http://www.s-und-n.de -

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-08 Thread Guido Casper
up with a full featured workflow engine still simple to use from Cocoon for simple use cases, I would immediately use that. Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-08 Thread Guido Casper
Gianugo Rabellino wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Gianugo Rabellino wrote: ... I'm afraid it's not that simple. Your workflow allows only for a linear flow, where you have only one way to go in the opposite directions (back and forth). But quite

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-07 Thread Guido Casper
Guido Casper wrote: The major drawback currently is that my AbstractState has to know about all the other states (to prevent each State class having to know about all the other states) and (when adding NewState) has to be updated with: allowEnterNewState(doc, user) {return false;} I have the

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-07 Thread Guido Casper
rying a comment. I think the repository is implementation specific and shouldn't be part of the interface. Agreed. Guido The user might also be regarded as an aspect of the manager's state but I am less sure of that. -- Unico -- Guido Casper

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-07 Thread Guido Casper
Gianugo Rabellino wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Interesting. would you like to share that with us? I think it would be avery good exercise to see the two approaches one beside the other. I don't have interest in generating my complete workflow logic out of a UML diagramm or a XML fi

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-07 Thread Guido Casper
Stefano Mazzocchi wrote: Guido Casper wrote: Stefano Mazzocchi wrote: If FSM work bad for flow, why would they work any better for workflow? After thinking again about ways to use continuations with workflow I came to the conclusion this might well be possible. But it looks awkward to me

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-06 Thread Guido Casper
while workflow logic looks like an everlasting loop of simple conditional logic with potentially lots of branches (the user "actively triggers" the workflow). Guido -- Guido Casper - S&N AG, Competence Center Open Source Tel.: +49-5251-1581-87 Klingenderstr. 5mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] D-33100 Paderborn http://www.s-und-n.de -

Re: Experience with workflow at Hippo Webworks

2004-03-06 Thread Guido Casper
ht a lot about it) but I couldn't think of how continuations make my life easier. Maybe that is because I don't think about workflow as being instances of something (but this seemed to go along with Stefano's thoughts). Now I'm not sure about that anymore ... Guido --

Re: workflow block commited

2004-02-29 Thread Guido Casper
Gregor J. Rothfuss wrote: hi, the lenya community has developed a lightweight workflow that we thought would make more sense as a cocoon block, especially given that other cms built on cocoon have shown interest in using it (hi arje :). i split out the generic part and made it into a (unstable)

Re: [RT] Cocoon Input Model

2004-02-29 Thread Guido Casper
Steve Krulewitz wrote: I agree that more sophisticated input handing would make general web applications much easier to write in Cocoon... here are some more random thoughts on the subject: Input can come from many sources: - http query string - http post stream - http cookie - user session obj

Re: [RT] Cocoon Input Model

2004-02-27 Thread Guido Casper
Alan wrote: What do you mean by strongly typed? Are we discussiong form posts here? Yes, form posts being the use case at hand, but there are other ways input may be provided. Quoting Daniel: Besides using request parameters and "structured" request parameters as user input. XML is used for

  1   2   >