> You can't. Scid enforces the laws of chess here and does not accept 
> invalid moves. In your case this is actually a drawback, in most others 
> it is definitely an advantage.

Well, one need not exclude the other. Enforcing laws normally but having
some "force invalid move" option/button/whatever could be of noticeable
help. Leaving apart chess, it could also make it possible to use scid as
a pad for entering chess variant games.

> I fear the only work around is the same as you'd use for C960 games: 
> store the first part of your game till the invalid castling, then create 
> a new game with the starting position of the castled king. If you don't 
> reorder your base you could switch to the continuation Game / Load Next 
> game (Ctrl-down). Not elegant, I agree.

Yeah, I know this workaround, but here it is even worse than in chess960
where the "invalid" castle lasts just one move. If wrong position lasts
for 5-10 oves, then I both need to reconstruct it in mind without any
help from scid, and loose the ability to replay it and show what was
going on.

> I'd only have a work around here as well. You can copy the notation as 
> far as you got it to the clipboard (system clipboard not the clipbase). 
> File / Copy game to clipboard from PGN window or, if you use cvs version 
> Ctrl-C, which adds to clipbase and the current game to the clipboard. 
> Then you can  put it into some editor buffer (I guess you've emacs 
> opened all the time anyway), change the move in question there and use 
> Tools / Import one PGN game to get it back into your base. Not elegant, 
> but well, better than redoing everything.

I am not sure whether it is really less work than reclicking a variation
;-)

> I fear this is not easily possible.
> (...)
> I fear the same as for a).
>
> Both might involve a bunch of technicalities in the backend. I'm not 
> sure but I'd not expect this behaviour to be fixed to your use cases 
> especially in the short term.

Well, I just make a suggestion for some future consideration.

>From what I saw, the problems I faced (entering and preserving invalid
games and reconstructing game from incomplete/partially wrong score)
are fairly popular, especially when paper scores and amateur level
competitions are considered. So a tool which would offer reasonable
help here could get some new "points" among people, khem, khem.

Of course I can't expect any immediate actions, just wanted to let you
consider those scenarios.

Regards.


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The modern datacenter depends on network connectivity to access resources
and provide services. The best practices for maximizing a physical server's
connectivity to a physical network are well understood - see how these
rules translate into the virtual world? 
http://p.sf.net/sfu/oracle-sfdevnlfb
_______________________________________________
Scid-users mailing list
Scid-users@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/scid-users

Reply via email to