[Bug 785702] Re: F8 should set input focus on search box

2011-05-23 Thread Eric Gregory
Jeff, I think you've hit the nail on the head -- at times, users might want the Find bar to appear without losing focus. It's a small use- case, I agree, but F8 is intended more as a toggle for the toolbar whereas Ctrl-F is intended specifically for finding something with text (much like in Firefo

[Bug 785702] Re: F8 should set input focus on search box

2011-05-20 Thread Jeff Van Epps
I guess I'm not "getting it". Would putting input focus in the box on F8 interfere with the user doing something else? What? I've tried a few things (e.g. ctrl-5, shift-ctrl-X) and they still function as expected even when the box has focus. The only place I can see it would be an issue is if you w

[Bug 785702] Re: F8 should set input focus on search box

2011-05-20 Thread Lucas Beeler
We've thought about this extensively and this behavior is by design. Ctrl+F is an Edit menu command that works the same way Ctrl+F works in Firefox or GEdit: it allows the user to perform a text search immediately. But the Shotwell search bar is about a lot more than just text searching: you can f