[Bug 107322] Re: firewire hard disk only detected at boot process

2008-05-17 Thread Jean-Baptiste Lallement
This bug report is being closed due to your last comment regarding this being fixed with an update. For future reference you can manage the status of your own bugs by clicking on the current status in the yellow line and then choosing a new status in the revealed drop down box. You can learn more a

[Bug 107322] Re: firewire hard disk only detected at boot process

2007-08-22 Thread Stefan Richter
PS: Those /dev/disk/by-id/* symlinks are automatically created by 'udevd'. If Ubuntu's udevd and the udev scripts are reasonably close to mainline udev, then it works out-of-the box with firewire-sbp2 just like with sbp2. -- firewire hard disk only detected at boot process https://bugs.launchpa

[Bug 107322] Re: firewire hard disk only detected at boot process

2007-08-22 Thread Stefan Richter
I'm not sure what is required to have it show up on the desktop. Perhaps an update to 'hald' to adapt it to the new drivers. (But then, firewire-sbp2 simply adds and removes SCSI devices like sbp2 and any other SCSI driver for hotpluggable SCSI devices does. It would moderately surprise me if HAL

[Bug 107322] Re: firewire hard disk only detected at boot process

2007-08-22 Thread Stefan Richter
Regarding FireWire disks, there are a few open bugs in the new driver stack (devices not recognized, errors during heavy I/O, and other issues). I estimate that most of them can be resolved before upstream kernel 2.6.24 will be released. The difficult part is handling of FireWire camcorders, audi

[Bug 107322] Re: firewire hard disk only detected at boot process...

2007-08-21 Thread murrayf
Hello Stefan, Thank you for your info, I didn't pretend to solve everybody's firewire troubles, my intention was to inform ubuntu users, that newer kernels can "let them manage better" firewire disks. Anyway, let's wait for better perfomance of the new stack in future kernel releases. Alb

[Bug 107322] Re: firewire hard disk only detected at boot process

2007-08-21 Thread Stefan Richter
The new alternative experimental drivers (CONFIG_FIREWIRE) are not ready for production yet, unless distributors know exactly what they are doing. Support by userspace libraries and applications is still lacking, and there are some hardware incompatibilities. See http://wiki.linux1394.org/Introdu

[Bug 107322] Re: firewire hard disk only detected at boot process

2007-04-24 Thread adam f
I have the same problem... (although I don't see two equal icons) on Ubuntu dapper drake 6.06 udevmonitor reveals (literally) nothing when I plug or unplug firewire drive if it is not connected at boot time. $ dmesg | grep 1394 reveals: [17275987.836000] ieee1394: impossible ack_complete from n