Re: SolrCloud and hardcoded 'id' field

2013-02-13 Thread Mark Miller
Ah, you mention most of the SolrCloud ones don't look like a problem. The other two then: 1. RealTimeGetComponent - doesn't look like a schema field usage, don't see a problem. 2. HashBasedRouter - looks like it could be a problem and this is new for 4.1 - this is something we should document w

Re: SolrCloud and hardcoded 'id' field

2013-02-13 Thread Mark Miller
A search for "id" is much too broad. I looked at 3 of the SolrCloud classes you mention and none of those "id"'s have anything to do with the unique field in the schema. I have not looked at the hash based router, but if you find a real issue then please file a JIRA issue. - Mark On Feb 12, 2

Re: SolrCloud and hardcoded 'id' field

2013-02-12 Thread Shawn Heisey
On 2/12/2013 7:54 PM, Shawn Heisey wrote: On 2/11/2013 7:47 PM, Mark Miller wrote: Doesn't sound right to me. I'd guess you heard wrong. I did a search for "id" with the quotes throughout the branch_4x source code. After excluding test code, test files, and other things that looked like they

Re: SolrCloud and hardcoded 'id' field

2013-02-12 Thread Shawn Heisey
On 2/11/2013 7:47 PM, Mark Miller wrote: Doesn't sound right to me. I'd guess you heard wrong. I did a search for "id" with the quotes throughout the branch_4x source code. After excluding test code, test files, and other things that looked like they have good reason to be hardcoded, I was l

Re: SolrCloud and hardcoded 'id' field

2013-02-12 Thread Michael Della Bitta
Apparently this was a side effect of the custom sharding feature. There is a fix planned, but I don't know more about it than that. Michael Della Bitta Appinions 18 East 41st Street, 2nd Floor New York, NY 10017-6271 www.appinions.com Where Influ

Re: SolrCloud and hardcoded 'id' field

2013-02-11 Thread Mark Miller
Doesn't sound right to me. I'd guess you heard wrong. - mark Sent from my iPhone On Feb 11, 2013, at 7:15 PM, Shawn Heisey wrote: > I have heard that SolrCloud may require the presence of a uniqeKey field > specifically named 'id' for sharding. > > Is this true? Is it still true as of Solr

SolrCloud and hardcoded 'id' field

2013-02-11 Thread Shawn Heisey
I have heard that SolrCloud may require the presence of a uniqeKey field specifically named 'id' for sharding. Is this true? Is it still true as of Solr 4.2-SNAPSHOT? If not, what svn commit fixed it? If so, should I file a jira? I am not actually using SolrCloud for one index, but my worr