Re: [Rd] NY Times article

2009-01-11 Thread Nicholas Lewin-Koh
Hi Frank, Thank you for the correction, I don't work in clinical, so good you keep me honest. Nicholas On Sun, 11 Jan 2009 09:21:23 -0600, "Frank E Harrell Jr" said: > Nicholas please note that FDA does not require type III sums of squares, > LOCF, and the use of any particular software. It is j

Re: [Rd] NY Times article

2009-01-11 Thread Frank E Harrell Jr
Nicholas please note that FDA does not require type III sums of squares, LOCF, and the use of any particular software. It is just the fact that FDA does not disallow type III tests and LOCF that prevents pharma from abandoning these terrible methods. Frank -- Frank E Harrell Jr Professor an

Re: [Rd] NY Times article

2009-01-10 Thread Jb
Hi all, One relatively easy solution is to include R and all relevant versions of packages used in (a) a reproduction archive and/or (b) packaged inside a virtual machine. With storage space cheap and sources of both R and packages available (and easy free crossplatform virtual machine sol

Re: [Rd] NY Times article

2009-01-10 Thread Nicholas Lewin-Koh
Hi, Unfortunately one of the the cornerstones of the validation paradigm in the clinical world (as I understand it) is that consistency/repeatability, documentation (of the programs consistency and maintenance) and adherence to regulatory requirements take supremacy even ironically over correctness

Re: [Rd] NY Times article

2009-01-09 Thread Kevin R. Coombes
Hi Nicholas, You raise a very good point. As an R user (who develops a couple of packages for our own local use), I sometimes find myself cringing in anticipation of a new R (or BioConductor) release. In my perception (which is almost certainly exaggerated, but that's why I emphasize that it

Re: [Rd] NY Times article

2009-01-09 Thread Nicholas Lewin-Koh
Hi, Kudos, nice exposure, but to make this more appropriate to R-devel I would just like to make a small comment about the point made by the SAS executive about getting on an airplane yada yada ... 1) It would seem to me that R has certification documents 2) anyone designing airplanes, analyzing c

Re: [Rd] NY Times article

2009-01-08 Thread Prof Brian Ripley
It has been all over R-help, in several threads. https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-help/2009-January/184119.html https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-help/2009-January/184170.html https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-help/2009-January/184209.html https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-help/2009-January/184232.h