Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-09 Thread Ross Finlayson
> 1. Do you think the naming convention (registeredProxyStream-N) for > REGISTERED streams will adequately support most users / use cases? This has > been convenient in my particular case and allows me to proceed with my > current efforts, however, I'm not sure it is the best approach. Would ha

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-09 Thread Bob Bischan
Ross, Works perfectly! Just a few thoughts for your consideration: 1. Do you think the naming convention (registeredProxyStream-N) for REGISTERED streams will adequately support most users / use cases? This has been convenient in my particular case and allows me to proceed with my current effor

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-08 Thread Ross Finlayson
> I did not see a way to send a REGISTER command to the Proxy Server. We have code that allows a RTSP server to register one of its *own* streams with a proxy server (or with a client application). We don't have code that allows some 3rd-party application to send a "REGISTER_REMOTE" (not "REGIS

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-08 Thread Bob Bischan
Many thanks for the on-going dialog! My evaluation of the Proxy Server / Live Media is probably going to lead to total dependence :-) openRTSP and the entire live555 library is very much on our radar screen. I'm still becoming familiar with the various pieces and parts. I did spend some time looki

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-08 Thread Ross Finlayson
On Oct 8, 2013, at 10:48 AM, Bob Bischan wrote: > Attached is the diagnostic output. > > Looks like the client is sending a TEARDOWN... Yes, your client (VLC) is sending a TEARDOWN. I don't know why; did you click the 'stop' button? Or perhaps it sent a TEARDOWN because it didn't receive a

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-08 Thread Bob Bischan
Attached is the diagnostic output. Looks like the client is sending a TEARDOWN... Thanks, Bob On Tue, Oct 8, 2013 at 10:30 AM, Ross Finlayson wrote: > When I connect to the registered stream using VLC > > > FYI, it's better (and easier) to use "openRTSP" (or "testRTSPClient") as > your clien

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-08 Thread Ross Finlayson
> When I connect to the registered stream using VLC FYI, it's better (and easier) to use "openRTSP" (or "testRTSPClient") as your client when testing a server, because you'll also get to see the RTSP protocol exchange at the client end. > I see "ProxyServerMediaSubsession["H264"]::createNewStre

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-08 Thread Bob Bischan
Ross, Thanks for your time and consideration with making the modifications. I have tested the new code and have a few observations to pass along: I see "Play this stream using the URL: rtsp://:8554/registeredProxyStream-1" when I send the REGISTER_REMOTE command. Proxy Server connects to the str

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-07 Thread Ross Finlayson
> Ok...that makes sense. Any idea how Proxy Server would handle the following > url? > > rtsp://:/axis-media/media.amp?resolution=480x270&fps=3&compression=40&videokeyframeinterval=18 OK, I hadn't anticipated complicated back-end stream URLs like this. So I've gone ahead and changed the way tha

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-07 Thread Bob Bischan
Ross, Ok...that makes sense. Any idea how Proxy Server would handle the following url? rtsp://:/axis-media/media.amp?resolution=480x270&fps=3&compression=40&videokeyframeinterval=18 >From debug I can see ProxyServer handles the new subsession like this: ProxyServerMediaSession["rtsp://99.58.86.

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-07 Thread Ross Finlayson
> Thanks for the update...I am now getting debug output. > > I see that the rtsp://url I am registering adds a new > "ProxyServerMediaSubsession with periodic OPTION requests from the Proxy > Server to the stream. Everything appears normal, but I'm not sure how to > access the proxy stream now

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-07 Thread Bob Bischan
Ross, Thanks for the update...I am now getting debug output. I see that the rtsp://url I am registering adds a new "ProxyServerMediaSubsession with periodic OPTION requests from the Proxy Server to the stream. Everything appears normal, but I'm not sure how to access the proxy stream now. Do REG

Re: [Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-07 Thread Ross Finlayson
> I have been trying to use the new REGISTER option with Proxy Server and have > not been able to make this work. Has anyone used this feature? If so, any > input on how to implement this feature would be greatly appreciated. > > When running an instance of Proxy Server with -V -R options set I

[Live-devel] Proxy Server REGISTER option

2013-10-07 Thread Bob Bischan
Hi, I have been trying to use the new REGISTER option with Proxy Server and have not been able to make this work. Has anyone used this feature? If so, any input on how to implement this feature would be greatly appreciated. When running an instance of Proxy Server with -V -R options set I do not