Re: Need advice on building a Cyrus IMAP cluster

2009-08-13 Thread Dave McMurtrie
Michael Sims wrote: > Hi Dave, > > Dave McMurtrie wrote: >> As of Cyrus 2.3, the code supports the notion of application-level >> replication. It's near real-time replication of all the application >> data, but one copy of the data isn't live. This is more of an >> active/passive solution, since

Re: Need advice on building a Cyrus IMAP cluster

2009-08-12 Thread Vincent Fox
Michael Sims wrote: Quick question on this. If I setup an active/passive cluster and put the mail spool AND all of the application data on a SAN that both nodes have access to (not simultaneously, of course), doesn't that bypass the need for using "mupdate_config: replicated"? Thanks... Th

RE: Need advice on building a Cyrus IMAP cluster

2009-08-12 Thread Michael Sims
Hi Dave, Dave McMurtrie wrote: > As of Cyrus 2.3, the code supports the notion of application-level > replication. It's near real-time replication of all the application > data, but one copy of the data isn't live. This is more of an > active/passive solution, since you have to do something to m

Re: Need advice on building a Cyrus IMAP cluster

2009-08-04 Thread Dave McMurtrie
Michael Sims wrote: > Overall, my general feeling is that active/active is still a bit too > bleeding edge for me to recommend it to my boss. Bleeding edge? VMS had this figured out ages ago :) > I know that it has been > done, but it seems to be relatively uncommon. I might try to toy around

RE: Need advice on building a Cyrus IMAP cluster

2009-08-04 Thread Michael Sims
Hi Dave, Thanks for taking the time to respond. Dave McMurtrie wrote: > When I worked at the University of Pittsburgh, we set up a 4-node, > active/active Cyrus IMAP cluster. It ran on Sun v440 servers running > Solaris 8 using Veritas Cluster Filesystem. If you need additional > d

Re: Need advice on building a Cyrus IMAP cluster

2009-08-03 Thread Dave McMurtrie
Dave McMurtrie wrote: > Though I have no experience with it, I seem to recall that someone > attempted to use GFS with an active/active Cyrus cluster and it was a > disaster. It was mentioned either on info-cyrus or in the Cyrus wiki. > If google doesn't help you find this, I can try to rememb

Re: Need advice on building a Cyrus IMAP cluster

2009-08-03 Thread Dave McMurtrie
recommendations do people have for the file system? GFS? > OCFS2? something else? When I worked at the University of Pittsburgh, we set up a 4-node, active/active Cyrus IMAP cluster. It ran on Sun v440 servers running Solaris 8 using Veritas Cluster Filesystem. If you need additional detail

Need advice on building a Cyrus IMAP cluster

2009-08-03 Thread Michael Sims
Hi, My company has been a happy user of Cyrus IMAP for over 6 years now. But our existing email infrastructure is starting to age a bit and I've been assigned the task of upgrading it. Although we only have about 5,000 or so accounts, we have experienced some performance issues over the years (f

Re: Cyrus IMAP cluster

2005-12-29 Thread Mathieu Arnold
+-Le 29/12/2005 14:52 -0500, Dave McMurtrie a dit : | Nikola Milutinovic wrote: | |> |> Are we talking about cyrus murder? I'll definitely take a look. | | He's actually talking about the replication code that David Carter wrote. | Murder only offers scalability, and does not give you any type

Re: Cyrus IMAP cluster

2005-12-29 Thread Nikola Milutinovic
Igor Brezac wrote: On Wed, 28 Dec 2005, Nikola Milutinovic wrote: Hello all. How would one go about building a Cyrus cluster? Suppose you wanted to make two servers a failover IMAP cluster. The way I imagine it, the MTA can forward messages to two servers. Problem is, deleting from one se

Re: Cyrus IMAP cluster

2005-12-29 Thread Dave McMurtrie
Nikola Milutinovic wrote: Are we talking about cyrus murder? I'll definitely take a look. He's actually talking about the replication code that David Carter wrote. Murder only offers scalability, and does not give you any type of replication of the backend mailstore. Thanks, Dave C

Re: Cyrus IMAP cluster

2005-12-29 Thread Sven Mueller
Nikola Milutinovic schrieb: > How would one go about building a Cyrus cluster? > > Suppose you wanted to make two servers a failover IMAP cluster. The way > I imagine it, the MTA can forward messages to two servers. Problem is, > deleting from one server will not reflect on the other. I'd like to

Re: Cyrus IMAP cluster

2005-12-28 Thread Igor Brezac
On Wed, 28 Dec 2005, Nikola Milutinovic wrote: Hello all. How would one go about building a Cyrus cluster? Suppose you wanted to make two servers a failover IMAP cluster. The way I imagine it, the MTA can forward messages to two servers. Problem is, deleting from one server will not reflect

Cyrus IMAP cluster

2005-12-28 Thread Nikola Milutinovic
Hello all. How would one go about building a Cyrus cluster? Suppose you wanted to make two servers a failover IMAP cluster. The way I imagine it, the MTA can forward messages to two servers. Problem is, deleting from one server will not reflect on the other. I'd like to build a "mirror" clust

Re: cyrus-IMAP cluster

2005-01-11 Thread Paolo Negri
I don't know if in your case a cluster is the better solution. If i should evolve my cyrus configuration i would evaluate aggregator http://asg.web.cmu.edu/cyrus/ag.html as first possibility. It's a solution conceptually in the middle between perdition and a cluster. One point of strenght of ag

Re: cyrus-IMAP cluster

2005-01-10 Thread Lee
We use drbd and heartbeat on the backend mail servers (active/passive, data is real time replicated from active->passive). Has worked very reliably for several years, however it is not the most clean solution. I've heard / read bad things about GFS based shared storage (cyrus wiki actually has

cyrus-IMAP cluster

2005-01-10 Thread Chad A. Prey
I am wondering if any of you out there are running cyrus in a cluster? If so, how did you do it? and how would you do it if you had to do it all over again? We are currently using cyrus with perdition which works fine, however, ideally the situation would be that a user could connect to either IMA