Re: [VOTE] graduate stdcxx to TLP

2007-10-15 Thread Martin Sebor
Thank you all for your comments. I assume everyone's questions so far have been satisfactorily answered and concerns addressed. Below is the resolution updated as Bill suggested. In the absence of further discussion I plan to close the vote at the end of the business day tomorrow (US/Mountain time

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Tuscany as a top level project

2007-10-15 Thread Matthieu Riou
On 10/15/07, Jeremy Boynes <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Taking a quick sample of the mailing list, the only contributors to > >> the discussion thread on Graduation, which I would assume would have > >> been a hot topic, were from the vendor. > > > > > > I remember contributing to discussion on

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Tuscany as a top level project

2007-10-15 Thread Robert Burrell Donkin
On 10/15/07, Paul Fremantle <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > 2) It has survived key members of the project jumping ship and forking the > code* > * Personally I think you should have disclosed your previous involvement in > this project to the IPMC when you started this thread. probably so: but

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Tuscany as a top level project

2007-10-15 Thread Paul Fremantle
> > I was thinking primarily of people who were on the TLP PMC proposal. > But yes, you and Matthew did help draft that proposal. I also took part in some other discussions. As the > diversity sub-thread was taken to the private list (which is kind of > ironic in itself) there may also have been

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Tuscany as a top level project

2007-10-15 Thread Paul Fremantle
I don't see that has any relevance to this discussion. If someone wants to do a presentation about Apache HTTPD focussing on mod_proxy and mod_rewrite it doesn't mean the other modules aren't important. Paul On 10/15/07, Jeremy Boynes <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On Oct 15, 2007, at 8:02 PM, Pa

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Tuscany as a top level project

2007-10-15 Thread Jeremy Boynes
On Oct 15, 2007, at 8:02 PM, Paul Fremantle wrote: Is it stated somewhere that the Java SCA/SDO components are "core" compared to C++ and DAS? And then in a coincidence of timing, there is this: http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/ws-tuscany-dev/200710.mbox/% [EMAIL PROTECTED] %3e wh

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Tuscany as a top level project

2007-10-15 Thread Jeremy Boynes
On Oct 15, 2007, at 8:02 PM, Paul Fremantle wrote: Jeremy Neither of the two independents are active in the core project areas of Java SCA or SDO (they are committing to the C++ implementation or to DAS). Is it stated somewhere that the Java SCA/SDO components are "core" compared to C++

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Tuscany as a top level project

2007-10-15 Thread Paul Fremantle
Jeremy Neither of the two independents > are active in the core project areas of Java SCA or SDO (they are > committing to the C++ implementation or to DAS). Is it stated somewhere that the Java SCA/SDO components are "core" compared to C++ and DAS? Taking a quick sample of the mailing list, t

Re: Soliciting mentors for Imperius project ... [VOTE] Accept project Imperius into the Incubator

2007-10-15 Thread Bill Stoddard
Craig L Russell wrote: Hi, I'm currently mentoring two other projects, so it's not clear how much time I can put in. With that disclaimer, I'm happy to volunteer as a mentor. Craig Thanks Craig! I expect to get the outstanding vote wrapped up by end of this week. Bill -

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Tuscany as a top level project

2007-10-15 Thread Jeremy Boynes
On Oct 13, 2007, at 10:07 PM, Noel J. Bergman wrote: Ant, Are there any issues that should be pointed out, such as the (hopefully) mechanical licensing header issue in stdcxx, or community diversity, which at least in part is measuring independence from corporate backing (a popular thread

October 2007 Incubator Board Report

2007-10-15 Thread Noel J. Bergman
The Incubator enjoyed another good month. Tuscany and stdcxx are in the process of graduation votes and preparation of TLP proposals. Ivy graduated into Ant. TripleSoup and JUICE are being put into a dormant status. "Pig" is *just* coming in, and "Imperius" should enter Incubation shortly. The

Re: [VOTE] Graduate Tuscany as a top level project

2007-10-15 Thread ant elder
On 10/13/07, Robert Burrell Donkin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On 10/13/07, ant elder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On 10/13/07, Robert Burrell Donkin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > wrote: > > > > > So bringing together all the comments so far gives something like: > > > > ...establish a Project Manage