Hey Edwin,
>From my perspective (building service-connected Gaia apps), this proposal
>makes sense: we should give developers the option of testing against real
>servers.
However, I think the proposal would be improved if it described the tradeoffs
of the mock server and real server approaches
I’m open to either options. So the current proposal is keeping tests with
external access *in the same directory* as existing tests governed by manifest
files. Good to know that adding another directory is something to avoid.
-edwin
On Aug 14, 2014, at 2:31 PM, Ehsan Akhgari wrote:
> On 20
On 2014-08-14, 5:00 PM, Edwin Wong wrote:
Hi Ms2ger,
Thanks for calling me on that, just trying to move things along.
Test location and using manifests concepts can also be decoupled. Wherever the
location the tests, we will use manifests to define it’s execution. There isn’t
really any oth
Hi Ms2ger,
Thanks for calling me on that, just trying to move things along.
Test location and using manifests concepts can also be decoupled. Wherever the
location the tests, we will use manifests to define it’s execution. There isn’t
really any other way around that.
So now the decision
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-
Hash: SHA1
On 08/14/2014 08:22 PM, Edwin Wong wrote:
>
> I think we're all in agreement. Adding support for manifest and
> mach/make option with the specific directory makes sense. To
> summarize:
>
> * land tests in a directory name "external" so it's easil
August 14, 2014 10:31:28 AM
Subject: Re: External dependent tests in gecko and gaia
I think this is a great idea, although like others have said, I'd like
to have this implemented inside the test manifests, regardless of
directory structure.
A related piece is reporting; for years, we've
I think this is a great idea, although like others have said, I'd like
to have this implemented inside the test manifests, regardless of
directory structure.
A related piece is reporting; for years, we've had tests like this run
on separate systems, reporting to custom dashboards, because they
> Anyways, now that gaia revisions are tied to m-c revisions with
> b2g/config/gaia.json, regression range hunting should be a matter of
> tooling around that, now.
>
That is excellent news.
___
dev-platform mailing list
dev-platform@lists.mozilla.or
On Wed, Aug 13, 2014 at 10:52:29AM -0700, Doug Turner wrote:
> Did we ever reach agreement about moving gaia into m-c? It would make
> this type of problem go away, and make regression range hunting much
> easier.
The gaia repo is massive, importing it in m-c would more than double
m-c's size.
An
On 8/13/2014 12:21 PM, Edwin Wong wrote:
> Hi dev-platform,
>
> TL;DR - Cloud Services and Quality Engineering would like to propose the
> creation of a directory named “external" in gecko and gaia repos for
> externally dependent tests.
>
> This enables features married to Cloud Services such
On 2014-08-13, 3:07 PM, Edwin Wong wrote:
Ehsan,
This wouldn’t be a top level dir, it would be as such:
• [area]/[framework]/external/test_example.js
• content/media/test/mochitest/external/test_loop.html
• gaia/apps/findmydevice/test/marionette/external/fmd_locate.py
Ehsan,
This wouldn’t be a top level dir, it would be as such:
• [area]/[framework]/external/test_example.js
• content/media/test/mochitest/external/test_loop.html
• gaia/apps/findmydevice/test/marionette/external/fmd_locate.py
-edwin
On Aug 13, 2014, at 11:58 AM, Ehsan
Hi Greg,
A few had discussed manifest vs directory separation of tests. I think the
directory idea took root because it’s easily identifiable from it’s path,
reducing collision with existing tests. I also agree, using directory as a
form of meta data is limiting. That said, both concepts can
On 2014-08-13, 12:21 PM, Edwin Wong wrote:
Hi dev-platform,
TL;DR - Cloud Services and Quality Engineering would like to propose the creation of
a directory named “external" in gecko and gaia repos for externally dependent
tests.
This enables features married to Cloud Services such as Loop, F
Did we ever reach agreement about moving gaia into m-c? It would make this
type of problem go away, and make regression range hunting much easier.
On Aug 13, 2014, at 9:21 AM, Edwin Wong wrote:
> Hi dev-platform,
>
> TL;DR - Cloud Services and Quality Engineering would like to propose the
On 8/13/14 9:21 AM, Edwin Wong wrote:
Hi dev-platform,
TL;DR - Cloud Services and Quality Engineering would like to propose the creation of
a directory named “external" in gecko and gaia repos for externally dependent
tests.
This enables features married to Cloud Services such as Loop, FindMy
Hi dev-platform,
TL;DR - Cloud Services and Quality Engineering would like to propose the
creation of a directory named “external" in gecko and gaia repos for externally
dependent tests.
This enables features married to Cloud Services such as Loop, FindMyDevice,
FirefoxAccounts, and Sync to
17 matches
Mail list logo
