Re: Moving to bin/solr start defaulting to SolrCloud mode?

2024-10-07 Thread David Smiley
Yeah, basically lean on SolrCloud vs non-SolrCloud and avoid as much as possible a name for non-SolrCloud. That said, I'm sure inside the codebase we have classes/comments referring to "standalone", and I don't think it's a bad thing for us maintainers. We know what this is :-) A renaming to "No

Re: Moving to bin/solr start defaulting to SolrCloud mode?

2024-10-07 Thread Gus Heck
Since we're here again, I like walter's suggestion. --cloud --no-cloud The attraction of this (to me at least) is that although "cloud" in Solr Cloud is a misnomer, "Solr Cloud" is the well known and popular name that everyone recognizes. Nobody will need to think to figure out what this option m

subscribe

2024-10-07 Thread Doug Coleman

Re: Moving to bin/solr start defaulting to SolrCloud mode?

2024-10-07 Thread David Eric Pugh
--legacy may be too strong a phrase, so leaning towards --classic as the parameter?   Will update the related PR's and see how they look. I'd love to get this to done this week if possible.   If that's rushing things, let me know. On Saturday, October 5, 2024 at 12:32:53 PM EDT, David Smile

Re: Overlapping arguments (SOLR-17383)

2024-10-07 Thread David Eric Pugh
I've created PR's for all these tickets, https://github.com/apache/solr/pulls/epugh to see them.    I'd love some review, and am hoping to merge them on my way to C/C NA tomorrow! On Saturday, October 5, 2024 at 04:37:59 PM EDT, Christos Malliaridis wrote: We are almost done addressin