Re: [DISCUSS] Replace UDP messaging for membership with TCP

2020-04-07 Thread Dan Smith
It looks like we have consensus to move forward with this proposal. Thanks all for your comments! I've moved it into "In Development" Thanks, -Dan On Fri, Apr 3, 2020 at 4:47 PM Aaron Lindsey wrote: > This proposal sounds good to me. +1 to using standard security > implementation based on TLS >

Re: [DISCUSS] Replace UDP messaging for membership with TCP

2020-04-03 Thread Aaron Lindsey
This proposal sounds good to me. +1 to using standard security implementation based on TLS > On Apr 1, 2020, at 3:20 PM, Dan Smith wrote: > >> When we move from a reliable UDP implementation to one based on TCP, we >> need to think about how to provide reliability on top of TCP. If you dig >>

Re: [DISCUSS] Replace UDP messaging for membership with TCP

2020-04-01 Thread Dan Smith
> When we move from a reliable UDP implementation to one based on TCP, we > need to think about how to provide reliability on top of TCP. If you dig > into TCP, you’ll find that it tries really hard (sometimes up to 15 > minutes!!) but doesn’t guarantee message delivery. Does this matter in > pra

Re: [DISCUSS] Replace UDP messaging for membership with TCP

2020-03-31 Thread Anthony Baker
Echo’ing my comment here: When we move from a reliable UDP implementation to one based on TCP, we need to think about how to provide reliability on top of TCP. If you dig into TCP, you’ll find that it tries really hard (sometimes up to 15 minutes!!) but doesn’t guarantee message delivery. Doe

Re: [DISCUSS] Replace UDP messaging for membership with TCP

2020-03-31 Thread Mark Hanson
Can we document the protocol this time? Thanks, Mark > On Mar 31, 2020, at 10:17 AM, Dan Smith wrote: > > Hi all, > > We created a RFC for replacing our UDP messaging in Geode with a TCP based > solution. This will address the issues we have supporting our current udp > encryption solution, a

[DISCUSS] Replace UDP messaging for membership with TCP

2020-03-31 Thread Dan Smith
Hi all, We created a RFC for replacing our UDP messaging in Geode with a TCP based solution. This will address the issues we have supporting our current udp encryption solution, along with helping us move away from jgroups, which currently can't be upgraded. Please review and comment by 4/7/2020