Re: Different binding addresses for traffic & membership

2021-01-20 Thread Dan Smith
I've been looking into the code a little bit to see if this is possible. I'm not sure it is right now. Here's some pointers at where to look at. Most of the magic is happening in JGroupsMessenger. JGroupsMessenger wraps jgroups, which we are using to UDP messaging related to membership. The fi

Re: Different binding addresses for traffic & membership

2021-01-20 Thread Aaron Lindsey
> Is there any way to configure a bind address to be used only for membership? To your first question, I asked around but I’m not aware of anything like what you are looking for. What you are describing does seem like it could become a common setup on Kubernetes, but I personally haven’t tried u

Re: [Proposal] - Cleanup Protocol Version Checks

2021-01-20 Thread Jacob Barrett
On Jan 20, 2021, at 10:36 AM, Owen Nichols mailto:onich...@vmware.com>> wrote: Sounds like good cleanup, but I'm not sure I understand why you propose breaking up the work and sneaking it in through mostly-unrelated PRs? My first thought would be do it in one shot, start by deleting the old

Re: [Proposal] - Cleanup Protocol Version Checks

2021-01-20 Thread Owen Nichols
Sounds like good cleanup, but I'm not sure I understand why you propose breaking up the work and sneaking it in through mostly-unrelated PRs? My first thought would be do it in one shot, start by deleting the old constants, and let the compiler guide you to all code that needs pruning. Or, if

Re: [Proposal] - Cleanup Protocol Version Checks

2021-01-20 Thread Jacob Barrett
Given the lack of objections to this proposal I have moved forward with some of this proposal. In deeper investigation it has come to light that GFE_82 was never used and appeared only as an artifact of open sourcing preparations. I have therefore retargeted GFE_81 as the oldest ordinal version

RE: Different binding addresses for traffic & membership

2021-01-20 Thread Alberto Bustamante Reyes
It seems this is not a trendic topic... 🙂 Let me share my approach by the moment, maybe this will receive more comments: I thought that it will be interesting to take a look at how the membership works (how the distributed system is created), to check if at some point I could decouple how the v