RE: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Bill Bryce
Thanks John, I appreciate your response. It is what I thought but I wasn't quite sure. I looked at MPICH2 for Windows and it does have two techniques with tradeoffs as you mentioned...I hope that you do decide to open up things a little more and allow other job schedulers and MPI stacks acce

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread Jim Lux
At 12:03 PM 4/3/2007, matt jones wrote: you say that, but don't PS2 and PS3 make ideal compute nodes for some applications like rendering and 3D and 4D (time as the 4th) ? a PS3 cluster is already out there somewhere... http://www.elecdesign.com/Articles/Index.cfm?AD=1&ArticleID=15229&bypas

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through? off topic

2007-04-03 Thread matt jones
> > Xboxes make good web servers for small scale. and use less > energy than a > > equivalent Piii or P4 system :-) > > gross. webserving is so easy that tiny embedded chips to a good job, > and something like a via low-power would do a great job. 95% of a game > console would

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread Mark Hahn
you say that, but don't PS2 and PS3 make ideal compute nodes for some applications like rendering and 3D and 4D (time as the 4th) ? I doubt it. while gaming consoles are admirably commoditized (actually sold at a loss in some cases), they're designed with constraints different fro

Re: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Peter St. John
John, Thank you for "... 4. If you want to learn more about Windows HPC clusters, I recommend checking out www.microsoft.com/hpc and www.windowshpc.net. I'm also happy to answer questions on this list, but frankly the S/N ratio tends to drop dramatically as soon as someone mentions Windows or Mic

RE: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Bill Bryce
Can I ask one simple question. Why did Microsoft have to do this (and I quote from MSDN) "Every job and task that uses Microsoft MPI must be submitted through the Microsoft job scheduler. There are several ways to submit jobs and tasks to the job scheduler:" I do not have that restriction wi

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread matt jones
you say that, but don't PS2 and PS3 make ideal compute nodes for some applications like rendering and 3D and 4D (time as the 4th) ? a PS3 cluster is already out there somewhere... especially if you take cost into account, a retail PS3 has the processing power (if you can access it) of

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread Peter St. John
Gaming driving supercomputing still makes me feel funny (but then, Ken Thompson and Belle so...). But I'm picturing ganglionic head nodes with KillerNic and playstations for compute nodes... Peter On 4/3/07, Greg Lindahl <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On Tue, Apr 03, 2007 at 02:26:17PM -0400, Kyle

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread Greg Lindahl
On Tue, Apr 03, 2007 at 02:26:17PM -0400, Kyle Spaans wrote: > On a related, yet more serious note: > Would something like this: > http://www.killernic.com/KillerNic/ > Be applicable to beowulf? Now that's weird: * it's an offload engine * it claims to "lower your ping" i.e. help short messages

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread Kyle Spaans
On a related, yet more serious note: Would something like this: http://www.killernic.com/KillerNic/ Be applicable to beowulf? Could the onboard Linux system help to prioritize MPI traffic? Or is it kind of pointless when you can just buy extra NICs for $10 - instead of $200 for one of these babie

Re: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Toon Knapen
Robert G. Brown wrote: In the current case if the government says "we will not fund any cluster and research software development that uses non-portable constructs in their MPI implementation" But their (MPI) API is still standard conforming. The way they integrated it (in the OS) is a bit

Re: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Greg Lindahl
On Tue, Apr 03, 2007 at 10:58:55AM -0400, Robert G. Brown wrote: > Security changes? To MPI itself? This puts them into a somewhat grey > area with regard to the GPL, doesn't it... that viral thing. MPICH is BSD licensed. Quite a few closed source MPIs are based on it. -- greg

Re: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Robert G. Brown
On Tue, 3 Apr 2007, Toon Knapen wrote: Robert G. Brown wrote: It isn't completely crazy that the US government would intervene here if they broke MPI portability. After all, MPI exists at all primarily because of direct government intervention (unlike PVM, which exists because some Very Brigh

Re: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Toon Knapen
Robert G. Brown wrote: It isn't completely crazy that the US government would intervene here if they broke MPI portability. After all, MPI exists at all primarily because of direct government intervention (unlike PVM, which exists because some Very Bright People conceived it and invented it and

RE: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Mark Hahn
on the original topic, to me, Beowulf is about cluster hacking. that is, a slightly subversive re-purposing to suit HPC. all hacking is based on something like a paradox, that if you simply break convention, there's a better way to do it. so rather than buy high-end supers and mini computers, st

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread Peter St. John
[RGB]... as I believe they are currently using the requisite socket for their head nodes ... I'm spitting up in my coffee. I had just been thinking, "I hope Creager and Brown don't resonate over this, it could make a great SF novel or destroy all life as far out as Tau Epsilon". Peter __

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread Robert G. Brown
On Tue, 3 Apr 2007, Gerry Creager wrote: Finally, complete documentation would have to be generated, and rgb or one of his clones has not stepped forward to offer such assistance. As he (or one of his clones) usually anticipates major innovations in technology and pre-writes said documentatio

RE: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Robert G. Brown
On Tue, 3 Apr 2007, Bill Bryce wrote: So this change effectively ties Microsoft MPI to only Microsoft Windows platforms, and the security changes are closed source. Not all of Microsoft's partners like MS MPI - when HP ships Microsoft CCS they remove MS MPI and put in HP MPI - which probably ju

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread Joe Landman
Gerry Creager wrote: > In general, water conduction requires a continuous column of water > unless you're willing to overdrive the signal to allow it to modulate an > intermediate air column. The presence of "solids" also modifies the > index of refraction and can induce standing waves and caus

RE: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Bill Bryce
Regarding the 'borgification' of MPI on Windowsthere is an opening for them to do this. MPI did not define how you start the tasks when you launch a parallel jobit left that up to the MPI implementation. Now most MPIs use something reasonable, like say ssh - or starting a mpd ring to launc

Re: [Beowulf] Win64 Clusters!!!!!!!!!!!!

2007-04-03 Thread Gerry Creager
I'm reminded here of an advertisement proposed, but never actually published, for Data General back in its day... "According to IBM, their entry into the minicomputer marketplace has legitimized it. The Bastards say, 'Welcome!'"... gerry Joe Landman wrote: Douglas Eadline wrote: I believ

Re: [Beowulf] Ethernet break through?

2007-04-03 Thread Gerry Creager
Peter St. John wrote: The one node refusing to send the doc, and the other note receiving it anyway, cracked me the *** up! Thanks P.S. the Google April Fool's actually got me thinking (network via plumbing). Water conducts acoustics real well. So a free peer-to-peer network within a city, or