Sean Estabrooks <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
    on Tuesday, September 16, 2003 5:27 PM said:

>> Because it's more informative and helpful.
> 
> Sure in certain cases.   But often it's more helpful just to give
> the command.

But how do you decide what's best for the poster? How do you know that a
simple answer is more helpful to them than a more lengthy one? Unless
they tell you outright it'd be really difficult to determine.

>>> In these cases especially, a quick answer solves their
>>> immediate problem and should provide inspiration for them on how
>>> to proceed in the future.
>> 
>> Should, but doesn't necessarily.
> 
> That's really up to the poster.

I agree, but the statement you made was not leaving it up to the poster,
you were leaving it up to your opinion, so that's where my response came
from.

>> Clearly?
>> 
> Yes, clearly.

Oh sorry I missed have missed the memo. ;)

>>> IMHO, more people are served by seeing the correct answer.
>> 
>> This is true.
>> 
> Wow, we agree on something ;o)

Yeah I'm the kind of person that thinks a correct answer is more helpful
than an incorrect answer. But that's just me.

>> Am I completely missing the point of your post?
> 
> Apparently ;-P

My memo machine must be broken. :(


Ta!

Chris.


-- 
redhat-list mailing list
unsubscribe mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list

Reply via email to