https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=356963

--- Comment #4 from qubo...@gmail.com ---
Non-blocking pop ups are great.

My feeling is that there's not enough information though. Not knowing profile
details can confuse, there can be profile duplicates, this question can make
you insecure in the "wait, what profile am I using anyway?" way. So I'd add
information about the current profile and include the main properties of both
profiles (resolution and frame rate)

As far as I'm aware of UI/UX concepts, I believe decision buttons need to be
clear, so all information should be in the popup and the buttons should be a
clear yes/no.

"Ignore" sounds like there's a problem, so I wouldn't use that.

I would suggest the message:

"Switch current project profile (HD 1080p 24fps, 1920x1080, 24fps) to clip
profile (DV/DVD PAL, 800x600, 24fps)?"

which is

"Switch current project profile (PROJECTPROFILENAME[can be trimmed],
PROJECTRESOLUTION, PROJECTFPS) to clip profile (CLIPPROFILENAME,
CLIPRESOLUTION, CLIPFPS)?"

and the options

"Continue / Cancel" or
"OK / Cancel" or
"Yes / Cancel" or
"Switch / Cancel"

Continue looks too similar to Cancel, so I wouldn't use it, even though it's
what the current project/project profile/change profile question offers (but at
least they differ in color there).

If possible, please test:
1. What happens when project bin is hidden during import of first
different-profile clip? (can be done via menu)
2. What happens when you press space or enter/return after importing first
different-profile clip? It should probably not select one of the two options
because one of them gets auto-selected.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to