https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=356963

--- Comment #11 from qubo...@gmail.com ---
Great work!
Testing video:
https://youtu.be/4ysOjreemUw

1. SVG is treated well now (resolution suggestion matches SVG size).

2. When images are added, the suggested FPS appears to be based on the current
project's. Seems like a very sensible solution!

3. The pop-up which shows up if the first clip doesn't match a profile I find a
bit confusing.
> No existing profile found for your clip (960x1061, 29,97fps)
> Do you want to switch to that custom profile?
> Yes / No

My thoughts are: what is a "custom" profile, question references other
sentence, making interaction possibly too long, "existing" profile might be
unclear as well.

I'd suggest
> Create and switch to new profile (960x1061, 29.97fps)?
> Continue / Cancel
With "Continue" being highlighted.

On one hand it would be nice if it would be in the project bin, just like the
other message is but on the other hand it is a more meaningful decision, so a
popup might be the right choice as well.

One could also have the popup only ask for creation of a new profile and if
it's answered positively, the usual "Switch to ..." message could appear
afterwards. But that might be too confusing and maybe problematic to implement.

4. I'd remove the "," before the " (" in
> Switch to clip profile DV/DVD PAL, (1920x1080, 25fps)?
to make it
> Switch to clip profile DV/DVD PAL (1920x1080, 25fps)?

5. I tested importing clips with project bin hidden. No crash, no freeze. You
simply don't get the "switch profile?" question unless you turn on project bin
which is probably not a problem.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to