issues  

Messages by Date

• 2024/11/27 [I] Java API get negative messageLength [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [FlightRPC] Bearer Token refresh design with retry mechanism [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Configuration does not provide a mapping for array column [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Add API for getBufferSizeFor() with density to BaseVariableWidthVector [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Make compression levels configurable [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Release][Java] Verify staged maven artifacts [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Rename compression classes [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] [Benchmarking] Large stdout when running benchmarks [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Standardise Logger naming [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java][Dataset] FileSystemDataset: Support reading dictionary arrays [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java/Python] Add unit test for pyarrow.timeX types in Array.from_jvm [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java][Gandiva] Expose Dremio build and tests as new optional container/test [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Port Row Set abstraction from Drill to Arrow [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] VectorSchemaRoot.create(schema, allocator) doesn't create dictionary encoded vector correctly [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Optimize bit operations performance [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Arrow-to-JDBC [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Gandiva][Java] Safeguard jvm before loading the gandiva library [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Make JniWrapper native method be public [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] FuzzIpcStream: Uncaught exception in java.base/java.nio.Buffer.createCapacityException [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Flight][Java][C++] Data read through Flight is having endianness issue on s390x [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] FuzzIpcFile: Uncaught exception in java.base/java.nio.HeapByteBuffer.<init> [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] FuzzIpcFile: Uncaught exception in org.apache.arrow.vector.types.pojo.Schema.convertSchema [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] FuzzIpcFile: Uncaught exception in java.base/java.nio.Buffer.checkIndex [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] FuzzIpcStream: Uncaught exception in java.base/java.nio.Bits.reserveMemory [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [C++/Java] Error when reading inner lists within a struct in empty outer lists from C++/Python in Java [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Docs][Java] Dataset Javadocs are not being published [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] FuzzIpcStream: Uncaught exception in org.apache.arrow.memory.BaseAllocator.buffer [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] ListVector#getBuffers returns buffers in the wrong order for usage of VectorLoader [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Spark job fails due to arrow buf limitation [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Problem to get current reservation of JVM direct memory on macOS Big Sur [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [FlightRPC][FlightSQL][Java] Make FlightSqlClientDemo a general purpose tool [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [FlightRPC][Java] CallbackBackpressureStrategy should not rely on listener.isReady() [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [IPC][Java] JDK 8 incompatibility with ByteBuffer.clear() [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] Add VarCharWriter#write(String) [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Java] java.lang.reflect.InaccessibleObjectException on Java 18 [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 Re: [I] [R][CI] Nightly job failures with `Failed to install qpdf` [arrow] via GitHub
• 2024/11/27 [I] [Python] Support lists of sources and destinations on `pyarrow.fs.copy_files()` [arrow] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 Re: [I] JWT token is invalid with Snowflake Go Driver - Python [arrow-adbc] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] R package fails to build against arrow 18.1.0: `error: 'ChunkLocation' in namespace 'arrow::internal' does not name a type` [arrow] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 Re: [I] [JS][Release] Wrong -.tar.gz name on arrow2csv fails when publishing [arrow] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 Re: [I] Reading multiple file corrupt values and is also order dependent [arrow-julia] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 Re: [I] Reading multiple file corrupt values and is also order dependent [arrow-julia] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Feature Request] Support lazy load/zero copy when using shared memory [arrow-go] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Python] Rewrite pyarrow.jvm using the C data interface [arrow] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 Re: [I] Change the default merge message [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 Re: [I] [Java] Test fails due to JSON key order [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Integrate Maven Spotless to CIs [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Avro to Arrow converter should reuse the same VectorSchemaRoot [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Development Java Substrait to call JNI Wrappers [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] VectorSchemaRoot#addVector() cannot add a vector to the end of the current vector collection [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] JDBC to Arrow converter iterator should reuse the same VectorSchemaRoot [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Add forward compatibility checks for unrecognized future MetadataVersion [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Replace multiple calls to getShort in NettyArrowBuf [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] JVM failed when use gandiva udf with dynamic libraries [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Remove Netty dependency from arrow-vector [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] MapWithOrdinal javadoc doesn't describe actual behaviour [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [FlightRPC][Java] CallStatus.metadata should get copied into the gRPC StatusRuntimeException [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] Arrow vector in Java(Scala) allocate byteBuffer error while read the bytes from Python pyarrow [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] ListVector's setValueCount does not set inner vector's value count correctly [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] Start using feature enums to value (umbrella issue) [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Use feature enum [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Flight][Java] Add optional session headers [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Improve documentation in regards to basic-usage / memory-management [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [FlightRPC][Java] Allow using a per-call Arrow allocator [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] Arrow vector in Java(Scala) allocate byteBuffer error while read the bytes from Python pyarrow [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] getObject API for temporal types is inconsistent and in some cases incorrect [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Implement non-sparse tensors [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [FlightRPC][C++][Python] Header-based auth in servers [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] Create build scripts and documentation for producing DLLs for JNI interfaces [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [FlightRPC][Java] Provide standard way to get client IP address [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] Bundle DLLs for JNI interfaces into Maven Jars [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][CI] Add testing to current java-jars builds and extend to JDK 11 and 17 [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][C++] Reorganize JNI code from several modules [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Improve testing of Dataset bindings [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [CI][Java] Automatically extract dependent library versions from pom.xml for s390x [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][C++] Separate JNI compilation & linking from main arrow CMakeLists [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [CI][Java] Use current cookbooks projects to validate new release versions [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Further Consolidate JNI compilation [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Ensure Flight with native Netty transport is actually being tested [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [C++][Java] Dataset: Support reading from fixed offset of a file for Parquet format [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] ListVector to return same UnionListWriter instead of returning new UnionListWriter [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Docs] Compare/contrast the Netty and Unsafe memory backends [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [FlightRPC][Integration] Ensure all RPC methods are covered by integration testing [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Docs] Document the use of the batchSize argument in Dataset ScanOptions [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][FlightRPC] Update benchmark to be on par with C++ [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 Re: [I] [Java] ArrowFileReader.getRecordBlocks() seems incompatibility with JDK 8 [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Memory][Core]: Initialize DEBUG variable in BaseAllocator class separately [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [FlightRPC][Java] Properties of JDBC driver are not autodiscovered by clients like DBeaver [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] NullVector constructor should not accept an arbitrary field type [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 Re: [I] [Java] Allow Arrow API to read file contents from inputStream instead of only Path [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] ErrorProne Warnings to be considered as Errors [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Netty memory release [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Introduce memory leak detector/handler utility to hook on unused unreleased buffers [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Make sure alignment and memory padding conform to spec [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Fix getField() for NullableMapVector [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Include compiled Flatbuffers sources in release artifacts [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] UnionListWriter does not behave properly when multiple lists are written in the same list [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Allow loading/unloading vectors without using FieldNodes [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Refactor metrics system [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] ComplexWriter should initialize nested writers when container vector is already populated [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Read and write record batches to shared memory [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Check if ArrowBuf is empty buffer in getActualConsumedMemory() and getPossibleConsumedMemory() [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Provide guidance in documentation for using Arrow in an uberjar setting [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Test fuzzer inputs [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Provide default setting of io.netty.tryReflectionSetAccessible=true [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Handle exceptions when flight service processes put requests [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] How to use RootAllocator in a low memory setting? [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Incorporate jmh benchmarks into archery [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] sbt docker publish fails due to Arrow dependecies [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Represent a data element of a vector as a tree of ArrowBufPointer [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Experiment with performance difference of avoiding the use of Avro Decoder [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [JAVA][C++]Support Parquet Read and Write in Java [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][CI] Pre-install the java dependencies in the dockerfile [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Bump checkstyle from 8.18 to 8.29 [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] offset buffer for vector of variable-width type with zero value count is empty [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Remove reader index and writer index from ArrowBuf [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Move ArrowBufPointer out of the java the memory package [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] FieldVector getFieldBuffers API should not set reader/writer indices [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Explore using Avatica as basis for Flight JDBC Driver [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Python] [ADBC_DRIVER] [FlightSQL] flight: no authorization header on the response (Unknown; AuthenticateBasicToken) when creating new connection. [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] How to implement cross database queries similar to presto [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Float16] Add IPC integration tests for float16 [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][CI] Move java-jars crossbow nightly build to Apache/arrow ASF runners [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] Create a stubbed FlightSQL sample application [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Python] Rewrite pyarrow.jvm using the C data interface [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] PySpark3 with pandas 1.1.5 and pyarrow 2.0.0 getting the below error [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] MurmurHasher doesn't take the final bytes into account if size % 4 != 0 [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][FlightSQL] Implement GetInfo (DatabaseMetadata) [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] AllocationListener should be called during ownership transferring [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][FlightSQL] Implement prepared statement [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][FlightSQL] Implement INSERT and UPDATE statements [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Dataset] Enable CSV file format [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Dummy NPEs in DefaultAllocationManagerOption [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] ZSTD compression issue [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Add support for sliced arrays in C Data Interface [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Request for enhancements to BufferAllocator.close() [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Unexpected Allocator states created after allocating buffer whose AllocationManager has different size from the requested size [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [CI][Java] Sporadic failure in {{testDirectReservationListener}} [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Move base memory component tests from memory-netty to memory-core [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Integration Test Needed for Decoding Dictionaries Using ZSTD Compression in Java [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [CI][Java] Check licenses of dependencies [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Doc] Add JavaDoc to TransferPair interface [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] C data interface: Add API to compute imported buffer size [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Remove deprecated methods from Java dataset module in Arrow 11 [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Windows] Intermittent failure to run unit test (failed: Error occurred in starting fork) [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Gandiva] Crashed tests: Error occurred in starting fork [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Compression closes uncompressed buffers [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][FlightRPC] Flight SQL JDBC driver improvements [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Potentially inefficient variable-width vector reallocation [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] implement index filtering for Table [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Doc] Define next steps for Arrow Tools module [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][CI] Java Support Version Policy [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Allow to set Compression Codec in Arrow Writer [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][FlightRPC] TestBasicOperation.getStreamLargeBatch is flaky on Windows CI [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Enable allocator logging in CI [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Release outstanding buffers when BaseAllocator is being closed [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] IndexOutOfBoundsException when loading compressed IPC format [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Test fails due to JSON key order [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Consume Substrait Plans [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][arrow-jdbc] Ability to customize JdbcConsumer construction [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Unable to read S3 files using Arrow Dataset [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Push-down filtering in Java [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] [Doc] Improve documentation for streaming file handling in VectorSchemaRoot [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Docs][Java] Update nightly docs to explain SNAPSHOT version [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][CI] Implement CI testing for Java JNI modules on Windows [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] The ArrowIPC Java library doesn't respect buffer offsets set in the flatbuffer metadata [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] BaseVariableWidthVector only supports 1 GiB through safe interfaces [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] UnionListWriter.writeVarChar get a empty string list [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [C++][Gandiva] Add a Secondary Cache to cache gandiva object code [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Development Java JNI Wrappers for Substrait (*.h , *.cc) [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Ability to use a path based host when using the JDBC driver [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Replace checkstyle with google-java-format or another formatter? [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] VectorSchemaRoot convertion into ArrowArrayStream [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Flaky test `ArrowFlightPreparedStatementTest.testPreparedStatementExecutionOnce` in JDBC Flight SQL driver [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] How do I read encrypted Parquet files using Arrow? [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Apache Arrow API fails with exceeded limit on max bytes to buffer when fetching data from snowflake [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Docs][Java] Install document uses <arrow.version>9.0.0</arrow.version> [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Should ListVector.reset() reset the position(index)? [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] FlightSqlClient Java Example [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Dataset][MacOS] Enable GCS [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Flight] How can a FlightClient connect to multiple servers? [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] DenseUnionVector is not transferred correctly [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [java] cannot read datasets with many columns [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][FlightRPC] Disable TestBasicOperation.getStreamLargeBatch on Windows CI [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [CI][Java][R] Improve notifications on failures for nightly R and Java jobs [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Unexpected RecordBatch length when saving empty table to file with compression [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] JDBC driver throws exception when loading system trust store on MacOS [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Slow LZ4 compression using java Arrow 12.0.0 [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Release candidate verification only use JDK17 for validation (request to add JDK8,11,18) [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Flaky tests meta-issue [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Force an outage of the client,server stuck in an endless loop [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] ArrowRecordBatch Body Length Computation Only Accounts for Last Buffer [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Find a proper way to test VM options (share system property between Main/Test code) [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Memory allocation alignment [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Finalize ErrorProne Warnings to be considered as Errors [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Python] Avoid Reuse VectorSchemaRoot for exporting ArrowArrayStream to other language [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [CI][Java] Remove excluded unstable tests when building java-jars. [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java] Some questions about the metadata api of jdbc [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][JDBC] JDBC Adapter execution failed for Mysql unsigned interger data [arrow-java] via GitHub
• 2024/11/26 [I] [Java][Windows][Substrait] Failed to parse memory address from string value. Error: stol argument out of range on Substrait Windows environment [arrow-java] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages