Hi, Thanks for looking into this release in detail; I haven't, but off the top of my head.
> 1. Missing RC designation in release URL This is not a requirement, and projects can name releases when they want. While using RC X is common, it’s not required. That naming does make it easy if another candidate for the release is needed. > 2. Multiple repositories bundled in single vote (requires separate votes) This is fine, and many projects do this. > 3. Built artifacts missing "incubating" suffix (98.3% non-compliant) Official releases on Infra-supported platforms need to be named this way, so yes, I think there seems to be an issue here, but perhaps this has not been common practice and has been missed. What may be more important is do the jars include an incubator disclaimer? > 4. Premature release tagging before vote completion GitHub tags are irrelevant as they are mutable; it's the hash that matters. Kind Regards, Justin --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
