Hi, > 1) If VP Legal or VP Infra says any of the issues are blockers then the > podling cannot do a release
I guess they well need to clarify that then, but AFAIK an an ex VP legal has said this, and VP infra has stated this for the exact issues mentioned in this release. > 2) If IPMC members want to become contributors and help fix the problems with > pull requests, or mentors (meaning real mentors not just folks pointing out > problems, then they should get started. As active members of the community > those individuals will have the right to vote -1 on a release. So are you saying that IPMC members vote are only valid for +1 votes on podlings they are not actively involved in and their -1 votes are invalid? The risk I see there is IPMC votes when needed just become just a rubber stamping exercise. > 3) If the podling is unable to gather three +1s among their active community > then they won't be able to do a release so the conversation is moot Well in this case here that happened (they only had one binding vote) and they asked the IPMC to vote on it. Some podlings, for a number of reasons, are not going to be able to find 3 active IPMC members in their project to vote on every release. (Although I'm surprised in this case given who the mentors are). Thanks, Justin --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
