On 2025-04-13 Chris Hofstaedtler <z...@debian.org> wrote:
> brian m. carlson (one of the git upstream copyright holders) claims 
> in Bug #1094969 that git cannot be distributed when linked with 
> OpenSSL. IIRC the Debian position is to use the system library 
> exception.

> Indeed our /usr/lib/git-core/git-remote-https links against 
> libssl.so.3, probably via libcurl-gnutls.so.4.

> To avoid introducing distro-wide changes at a time where this seems 
> inappropriate, an option is to disable building git with libcurl.

> Below is a simple patch to accomplish this. Barring any new insights 
> or feedback from the involved maintainers, this might be a way out. 

> I believe all relevant people are in CC:, and they can figure this 
> out.  Details can be found in the bug.
[...] 

Hello,

well, we have decided to use the system library exception because we
thought we had the right to so, not because we hoped that no copyright
holder would notice. Undoing this for specific packages where a
copyright holders tells us he disagrees undermines this position. Imho we
need to either with using the exception or somebody(TM) needs to do a
license analysis of our packages and we then need to implement coding
changes to weed out any and all GPL<->openssl linkage.

Personally I doubt we have the manpower nowadays to switch back from
linking against OpenSSL.

cu Andreas

Reply via email to