Hi,

> Are discussions at Salsa preserved years down the line?

I don't think there is any special concern to suspect that Salsa or
any other official Debian service would seize to exist abruptly?
GitHub.com and GitLab.com has done a pretty good job at hosting
contents for years and years, hopefully Salsa can too.  If another
service some day replaces it, I am confident that contents can be
migrated. We already successfully migrated git.debian.org to
salsa.debian.org.

Also note that the contents that really matter is the git repositories
themselves. The Merge Request feature is not intended to be a place of
permanent documentation. It is just a tool to facilitate fast and
accurate code review and efficient feedback among multiple
participants, and efficient publication and re-review of code. All
permanent documentation should to in inline comments, in READMEs in
the repository or when explaining specifically *why* a change was
made, it should be in the git commit message, and easily accessible
via git blame. If people have a need to read MR discussions, then the
git commit messages or git contents weren't done properly.

Reply via email to