[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Marco d'Itri) writes: > On Dec 11, Goswin von Brederlow <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >> Your case of hardware wich already includes firmware is totaly >> irelevant since Debian does not distributes hardware, does not even >> stand for free hardware nor do debs have to depend on hardware. > And why it should be different if that firmware is distributed by the > manufacturer on a CD instead of a flash EPROM chip? > > -- > ciao, | > Marco | [9711 deqGE2zroRuAE]
Because the user has to actively do something and taint his filesystem with the non-free files from the CD. If the system boots off the CD, loads the firmware and only then loads the linux kernel then it would be different. As a rule of thumb ask yourself: Can I take out the harddisk and sell it including contents? With non-free firmware copied from a CD you can't. You have to remove the firmware first. My 2c, Goswin