On Thu 28 Dec 2006, Vincent Lefevre wrote:

> The upgrade from wwwoffle 2.9-2 to 2.9a-1 overwrote a local change in
> /etc/wwwoffle/wwwoffle.conf (at least a comment I had added at the end
> of the file, which disappeared).
> 
> Section 10.7.3 of the Debian policy says:
> 
>   local changes must be preserved during a package upgrade

This is I think a question of interpretation;
if the local change modifies the way the package works in any way, then
I agree; but a comment?!  Where does it end? Do you want upgrades to
preserve the mtime of the configuration file as well? How about the
filesize, if that was changed locally?

Upgrading to certain versions of wwwoffle has always needed to update
the configuration file, otherwise the package simply doesn't work
correctly after the upgrade, and that would cause a lot more people to
file bug reports. All the user settings are preserved if at all possible
(it's not possible e.g. if an option goes away, although that hasn't
happened up to now IIRC). Besides, the original configuration file is
backed up, so if the comment was important to you, you can still find
it.

I'm inclined to disagree that a comment is a "local change" here,
especially as it does not influence the way the package works at all.


Paul Slootman


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to