Package: tar
Version: 1.16-2

I suggest that bzip2 should be made a dependency of tar, and not just a 
suggested package as it is today. The rationale is that the -j flag of tar will 
not work unless bzip2 is installed, and thus tar is not functionally complete 
unless bzip2 is installed.

A user who is making sure that all necessary tools required to run a certain 
script is installed, may not pay close enough attention to every tool's command 
line switches and thus discover only at a later time that the script fails. 
(Yes, this happened to me. ;) )

  $ tar cjf package.tar.bz2 file 
  tar: bzip2: Cannot exec: No such file or directory
  tar: Error is not recoverable: exiting now

Cheers,

Johan Hovold

Reply via email to