Henning Sprang <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [on 2006-07-29 00:16] wrote:
> Mike Horansky wrote:


> > Udevd is started differently in Dapper than in Sarge. Dapper uses
> > start-stop-daemon while  Sarge uses "udevstart".
> 
> I am missing the information about how you are using FAI.
> 

I'm sorry about that.

> Most important:
> 
> - are you using fai on an Ubuntu machine to install UBuntu, or on a
> debian machine to install Ubuntu?

My buildserver is debian sarge i386. For i386 Dapper, I run
make-fai-nfsroot on the sarge buildserver. For amd64 Dapper I
installed fai-server (2.10.5 from the FAI repository) on a preexisting
Dapper-amd64 box and ran make-fai-nfsroot there, then copied the
generated nfsroot over to the sarge buildserver.

The problem with udevd not starting up occurred in both situations. 

> 
> - which version of FAI do you try to run, which version is the install
> server, which version do you want to install.

I use only 2.10.5 packages from
http://www.informatik.uni-koeln.de/fai/download/sarge/.

> 
> in the cases that you use FAI on an Ubuntu machine, this report should
> go into the Ubuntu BTS. But I think in dapper is a working FAI version
> available where these bugs are fixed.

I noticed FAI packages in the ubuntu repository, but they are 2.10.1
only. It didn't occur to me that they may have specific fixes for
ubuntu.

>  In the case you are trying to install Ubuntu from a Debian machine,
> then it's not intended behaviour to try installing Ubuntu in the
> NFSRoot, there's a different method installing other distributions
> than the one of the install server, where the nfsroot is always the
> same as the distribution and version running on the server, only the
> base image changes.

If this is not considered a bug with upstream FAI, I can just document
the tweak in the FAI wiki somewhere.

My intention is to always use the same fai package and build server as
much as possible, and it seems that certain ubuntu-specific bugs (such
as not allowing unsigned debs to be installed without erring-out) have
been fixed in the past.

I understand, though, if this is not germaine to the upstream FAI.

-- 
-Mike Horansky, ITSS/Unix Systems and Applications
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]

OPINIONS EXPRESSED BY ME ARE NOT NECESSARILY SHARED BY MY EMPLOYERS.


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to