On September 10, 2014 1:16:14 PM CEST, Per Andersson <avtob...@gmail.com> wrote: >On Wed, Sep 10, 2014 at 10:35 AM, Stas <s...@childsplay.mobi> wrote: >> >>
>> As I said, I can never be 100% sure everything inside childsplay is >free, >> that was a valid point you made, so I assume it can never be part of >the >> Debian distro. >> That was my reason to ask you to remove it. >> I will also refrase the claim that everything is under the gpl and >move the >> childsplay package from savannah to github or back to sourceforge. > >I think it is better to keep the GPL license for everything and, as you >have done, resolve issues if they arise. Like I said, I never had problems with this approach and the two times it did arise the people where rather pleased with the swift action to remove the files in question. >The package will still be in unstable, and, when this bug is resolved, >it >will migrate to testing again. > >From my point of view thus bug can be closed with a new release >(depending on the sample from samplephonics). I could replace the sample from samplephonics with a sample the company I work for will donate to childsplay and be done with it. Would that be sufficient ? > >A side-track: archive.org has a truly massive list of free audio >content. >(Some content is not licensed properly though, so some care needs >to be taken when using stuff.) Thanks for the tip :-) > > >>> >>>[Stas] >>>> It's replaced with a free sample from the "freebies" section of >>>> http://www.samplephonics.com >>> >>>My concern is that these samples are not free as in DFSG free. >> >> I know, I've contact them to ask if the license also applies to their >> 'freebies' section as it's not very clear. >> I haven't yet received a reply. > >That is great! > > >> But again, please remove childsplay from Debian as I can never be >sure about >> every file inside childsplay. >> It's a problem with many programs that have a lot of graphics and >sounds. >> I'm sure that if you looked closely to similar programs you can find >files >> of questionable origin. > >This is the fact with many packages in Debian, the issues are resolved >as they come by. > > >> Btw, childsplay is since 2013 in 'maintenance mode' and the next >version >> will be a mobile/tablet version. > >Ok. > > >-- >Per Regards, Stas Zytkiewicz -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org
