On Wed, 24 Oct 2012, Paul Gideon Dann wrote:
Hi guys,
Great work on Calligra so far. I submitted a bug[1] that was quickly set to
WONTFIX, with a suggestion that I bring the problem to this mailing list. I
noticed the desire to polish Calligra, and thought it would be a great
opportunity to file the bug I think is the number 1 turn-off when approaching
Calligra for the first time.
The problem is the welcome dialog, that pops up when you first launch one of
the applications. As can be seen in my example screenshot[2], there is a lot
of empty space, the icons are blurry and lack colour, and the "Use this
Template" button is pretty small and tucked away. If this dialog is to stay,
I think it needs some serious love.
Well, it's an old discussion... This is actually the second generation
welcome screen, the first one looked a lot like what Apple now has for
Works
(http://www.valdyas.org/fading/index.cgi/hacking/krita/templates.html). If
you compile Kexi, you'll see there's yet another attempt at a welcome
screen.
The discussions about the template icons is just as old: the problem is
that nobody creates templates with good icons for Words or Sheets -- not
the kind of gorgeous templates that exist for iWork --
http://www.apple.com/iwork/pages/#easy.
And then there's the problem that we tried to have one common gui paradigm
for very different applications. That's broken already with the toolbox
changes in words, of course. For some applications, a welcome screen is
really necessary because there just doesn't exist a useful blank document
(stage, krita -- see also the welcome dialog for loimpress, or the
discussion about the default screen l&f for gimp).
When a finnish usability group investigated calligra, it actually found
that users didn't have a problem with the welcome screen -- many
developers feel it is horrible, and that it _must_ be bad usability, but
that's actually not borne out by the research.
All in all, it's a really complicated issue, which is also why not much
action has been taken.
More importantly, though, the dialog presents me with an immediate feeling of
frustration: "I just want to *play* with this application; why won't it let me
in?"
Well, that's another thing: you want to *play* with the application, the
screen is designed for people who want *work* with the application.
I'm blocked in my attempt to open it, and am forced to think pretty hard
about what it's asking and what kind of document I might want to write. I
think most people coming to Calligra probably won't know exactly what kind of
document they want to write; they'll just want to try it out. I believe that
template selection or opening an existing file is something that should be
done *after* the application has started and the user has been given a chance
to see the workspace; ideally in a sidebar or prominent toolbar of some kind.
But that would actually mean extra steps for a user who wants to do work.
Like currently with lowriter, where you start the application, get a more
or less useless default document, then go new/Templates and Documents to
select a template. The result is that most people I know load an old
document that was created with the right template, remove the content,
type new content -- and then if recording is on, there's an information
leak.
For me, this is a very serious usability concern. Not because it prevents me
from using the application so much (I'm a programmer too; I can tolerate these
things), but because it presents Calligra in a very poor light from the very
start.
I hope this is all taken in the spirit it's intended: in an attempt to improve
software that I really want to see succeed. I've gone to some pains to bring
this to your attention. Whatever you do, please don't dismiss it because you
could not achieve a consensus before, or because it might displease some of
the community. If some people want this dialog on startup, it should be
possible to turn it on, but it should definitely not be there by default.
Well, I can imagine that for some applications, like words or sheets, it
would be best to have it off by default, for other applications (stage,
krita) it might be best on by default. And since we've lost our aspirations
at consistency across the suite already, I wouldn't object if Boemann or
Mek would hide it by default, especially if there's a good default
template.
Boudewijn
_______________________________________________
calligra-devel mailing list
calligra-devel@kde.org
https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/calligra-devel
