Hi,


I am in the process of putting together make files for firmware builds and run 
into an issue that I didn't see addressed in any of the issues lists. One of 
the things I want to do is to tag the SVN revision that a binary was built from 
onto the file name (this was actually requested by manufacturing and I agree 
with their view point). The revision is easy enough to get from svnversion. The 
problem is, that when I run it  in my working directory, inevitably I get a 
mixed revision result, even if I have just committed (something like 3:26). 
While this may be informative to me as a developer, this is not something I can 
embed in a file name. At the same time Make has no ability to extract just the 
part after the colon.



I see three solutions to this problem:

  1.  create another directory and do a clean checkout of the version I just 
committed. I tried this and it works well. Cumbersome though.
  2.  implement an external tool that runs svnversion and then disassembles the 
result to get the correct number for use in a file name. Ugly, too many tools 
needed already to get every day work done.
  3.  implement an option in svnversion that makes it to only spit out the 
highest revision number (no colon). Alternatively, the colon could be replaced 
by any character the user likes. That way something compatible with the file 
system can be chosen. I guess what I meant to say is, it would be nice to have 
control over the format in which svnversion reports the version.

Thanks for taking the time to read and form an opinion about this.



Elmar


Reply via email to