[ please don't top-post, i.e. put your reply at the bottom (or inline) of the thing you're replying to. I reshuffled a bit below, to make the ordering more logical for this list. ]
On Tue, Dec 21, 2010 at 7:55 PM, riad benmouhoub <riad.benmouh...@gmail.com> wrote: >> On Tue, Dec 21, 2010 at 7:22 PM, Bob Archer <bob.arc...@amsi.com> wrote: >> >> > I experienced the following behavior with SVN. The steps i did are >> > : >> > >> > 1- I made changes in a file >> > 2- updated the file >> > 3- Checked in the file after the merge succeeded >> > 4- In the resulting file 6 lines disappeared. >> > >> > Is it considered as a bug? >> > has anyone experienced such a behavior? >> > >> >> If it truly is losing lines that would be a bug. >> >> However, what were the merged in changes? Are you sure the merge during >> the update didn't remove lines? >> >> BOb >> >> >> From: riad benmouhoub [mailto:riad.benmouh...@gmail.com] >> Sent: Tuesday, December 21, 2010 1:41 PM >> To: Bob Archer >> Subject: Re: SVN BUG : Lines disappeared after update and check in >> >> >> >> Hi Bob, >> >> >> >> Thanks for the quick answer. >> >> >> >> Well the thing is that I didn't perform a tkdiff after the update!! >> >> >> >> we are working with the following SVN version (I guess it is a bit old!): >> >> Subversion command-line client, version 1.6.5. >> >> >> >> I had this problem two times today after performing each time the same >> procedure i.e. update then check in >> >> >> >> Riad > On Tue, Dec 21, 2010 at 7:43 PM, Bob Archer <bob.arc...@amsi.com> wrote: >> >> I would do a diff between the rev that you update to, and the one before >> that. See if lines were removed. 1.6.5 isn't that old. >> >> ( you should reply all so messages go to the list too.) >> >> >> >> BOb > > I did so and the lines are there! > Riad I think you need to provide more details, before this can be confirmed to be a bug. Can you describe precisely what svn commands you executed? Maybe give a complete example, based on your experience (feel free to replace file/directory names with dummy example stuff)? Cheers, -- Johan
