I get the same thing: svn 1.6.5, Ubuntu 9.10. Doesn't seem right. For grins, I checked out a NEW copy of the repo, and it looks like passive
+ svn co file:///$PWD/repo new + head -v new/newdir/file ==> new/newdir/file <== $Rev: 1 $ svn st reports clean in all WCs. On Fri, Jun 11, 2010 at 14:56, Manuel Pégourié-Gonnard <m...@elzevir.fr>wrote: > Le 11/06/2010 21:42, Mike Dixon a écrit : > > On 6/11/2010 7:09 AM, Manuel Pégourié-Gonnard wrote: > >> Consider the following scenario: someone copies a directory, then > commit. Inside > >> this directory, there are a few files with the $Rev$ keyword set to be > expanded. > >> Another user updates his working copy to the same revision. Both look > at the > >> expansion of the $Rev$ keyword in the files: they are not the same. > >> > >> I'm quite surprised, since I would have expected this to be independent > of the > >> working copy used (as long as it's up-to-date, obviously). > > > > After committing, your working copy is not up-to-date. You need to > > explicitly call svn update. > > > Right, I forgot this step in my test script, but it was done in the real > situation where I first noticed this behaviour. > > Anyway, it doesn't change anything to this problem. Below is the new > version of > the script I'm using to test this, and its output. As you can see, I'm > doing a > svn up in the two working copies just before looking at the files, but > still get > different values for the expanded $Rev$. > > Manuel. > > ===== reproducer script ===== > #!/bin/sh > > LC_ALL=C; export LC_ALL > set -x > > svnadmin create repo > svn co file://$PWD/repo active > svn co file://$PWD/repo passive > cd active > svn mkdir dir > echo '$Rev$' > dir/file > svn add dir/file > svn propset svn:keywords Rev dir/file > svn ci -mdummy > svn cp dir newdir > svn ci -mdummy > cd .. > (cd passive && svn up) > (cd active && svn up) > head -v */newdir/file > > ===== script output ===== > + svnadmin create repo > + svn co file:///home/mpg/tmp/svnfoo/repo active > Checked out revision 0. > + svn co file:///home/mpg/tmp/svnfoo/repo passive > Checked out revision 0. > + cd active > + svn mkdir dir > A dir > + echo $Rev$ > + svn add dir/file > A dir/file > + svn propset svn:keywords Rev dir/file > property 'svn:keywords' set on 'dir/file' > + svn ci -mdummy > Adding dir > Adding dir/file > Transmitting file data . > Committed revision 1. > + svn cp dir newdir > A newdir > + svn ci -mdummy > Adding newdir > > Committed revision 2. > + cd .. > + cd passive > + svn up > A newdir > A newdir/file > A dir > A dir/file > Updated to revision 2. > + cd active > + svn up > At revision 2. > + head -v active/newdir/file passive/newdir/file > ==> active/newdir/file <== > $Rev: 2 $ > > ==> passive/newdir/file <== > $Rev: 1 $ >
