> More testing reveals that aliases are not needed. Here is what works: > > With Groups
I assume here you mean "with aliases" > > [aliases] > dev10 = dev1 > dev20 = dev2 > dev30 = dev3 > > [groups] > deva = &dev10, &dev20 > devb = &dev30 > > [/] > @deva = rw > @devb = r > > ------------------------------ > > Without Groups and here you mean "without aliases" > > [aliases] > > [groups] > deva = dev1, dev2 > devb = dev3 > > [/] > @deva = rw > @devb = r > > My problem was that I thought the ampersand was only necessary if you used > aliases. > > I hope this helps anyone else that may have had problems. > > Rich In both cases you are using groups. BOb