Le dimanche 9 mai 2021, 07:52:21 CEST Alexander Kriegisch a écrit : > Hervé BOUTEMY schrieb am 09.05.2021 03:31 (GMT +07:00): > > Le samedi 8 mai 2021, 17:03:05 CEST Alexander Kriegisch a écrit : > >> My question was how to achieve reliably predictable ordering. That > >> question is yet to be answered. > > > > it is answered: you currently can't. > > Actually, your first reply sounded like you explained some technical > background to me and wanted me to figure out the rest by myself. ok, I tried to be short and clear in the first paragraph, but I failed :)
> I did > not read it as "you currently cannot", my apologies. But actually, the > workaround Delaney sketched in his answer sounds viable. Would you > agree? Delany found a smart workaround to try to have full control about order in effective POM, then on build plan: nice idea, even if cumbersome If you don't play too much with profiles, inheritance, and don't expect too much control at execution level (instead of plugin), I suppose our effective POM building algorithm should not change the order in the future. Then you're still playing at your own risk with implementation details, but it may work sufficiently well. > > >> I am afraid (...) the thread will just trickle out. (...) my PR for > >> Maven Shade Plugin which did not get a single reaction, even though > >> it fixes an old problem, adding new functionality. But maybe I just > >> need to be more patient. :-) > > > > if you want to work with me, I'll be available on May 29th during Hack > > Commit Push to hack together on Maven: > > https://paris2021.hack-commit-pu.sh/#projects > > Actually, that would be awesome. I just cannot say if I can make it, > because I have a quite demanding daytime job as an Agile Coach too and > only program in my sparetime as a hobby. same here you know for every Maven committers > Furthermore, I am currently > working in time zone Southeast Asia. But thanks for the invitation, I > might register and participate if I can. don't hesitate to join only a few hours: having a small human interaction and discussion helps when we are between hobbyists > Actually though, I would prefer > raised issues and PRs being worked on independently of my participation > in such an event. I know that would be slower due to the asynchronicity, > if we need to discuss the PR, but at least possible. I hope we can get > that thing off the table and into Maven Shade the usual way, too. I > certainly did my share of work, commenting on issues and preparing a PR, > and I am willing to assist in any other way I can, promising to be > responsive whenever you ask something. Maven Shade Plugin is not part of the plugins I usually work on. Please put the link to your PR, I can add it to my already long personal TODO list and see if I have some spare time Regards, Hervé > > Regards --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
