This issue affects me directly.  I have been using 16.04.x for about 1.5
years and for most of that time updates (security and otherwise) have
been carried out just as I have directed.  However, not long ago I
discovered that updates were being carried out in the background with
disregard for the options I have chosen.  Unattended Updates has been
enabled and working in the background.  I had never heard of it and
could not find an interface to affect it.

I discovered it a few weeks ago when firefox 55.0.2 was pushed out.
Some one hadn't done enough beta testing and introduced a pretty severe
bug to a very large community of users.  I quickly rolled it back only
to find it reinstalled the next day. And, again the next.  Some one
decided that FF needed to be updated every day, without permission and
without notification.

After some investigation I found that some in the Ubuntu community have
openly supported this policy in order to "better serve"  the community.
Apparently, the sentiment is that the average user can not be trusted to
keep their own computer updated and thereby exposing the community to
risk.  It is for the good of the community as a whole.

The FF issue is a perfect example of a continuous distributed denial of
service imposed by policy. The people who turned "on" the unattended
upgrade policy are not listening to the feedback.  As of today, FF
55.0.2 is still severely broken (on my platform) and is still being
pushed out on any automatic or manual update unless unattended upgrades
are disabled completely or FF eliminated from apt upgrades manually.

Conclusion:  I did not turn this tool on.  In fact, I had selected to
turn everything automatic "OFF". No one asked me for permission. No one
notified me that a policy had been chosen for me that over rides MY
CHOICE - did I say that loud enough?.

I installed 16.10.x on a new laptop a month ago and I see that
unattended updates is installed and active - overriding my choices by
default.  In Software and Updates, I have all automatics turned off and
yet every night that system downloads and updates my computer.  Who the
hell are you people?

Yes, of course there is a way to turn it off - before some one tries to
tell me "all you have to do is...."

That is not the issue!  You turned it on!  I sincerely urge you to back
off your holly-er than thou point of view and honer end user choices.
NO more secret policy changes! And, no more unintended consequences
resulting from those policies. Should we not be able to trust you?

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1700930

Title:
  Default action policy for "Security Updates" changed between 14.04 and
  16.04

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/unattended-upgrades/+bug/1700930/+subscriptions

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to