** Description changed: Binary package hint: software-center Software Center version 4.0.1 We currently sort reviews in Software Center's details view based on upstream version number of the package, followed by "usefulness" of the review as voted by users, and lastly by date of the review. With the version comparison, reviews for previous upstream versions are pushed later in the list and are tagged with the line "This review was written for a previous version of <packagename> (Version: <upstream version number>)". For some packages, however, the sorting by usefulness for a given upstream package version is incorrect. For an example of this, see the attached screenshot that shows the list of reviews for the Inkscape package and note that the review by "dreamsare4living" with a usefulness of "3 out of 3" is incorrectly located *above* the review by "Erik B. Anderson" with a usefulness of "4 out of 4". Instead, the reviews should be sorted from highest usefulness to lowest for any given upstream version. + + TEST CASE: + 1. Open Software Center version 4.0.1. + 2. Navigate to the Inkscape package details view. + 3. Examine the list of reviews and note that the initial set of reviews for the current version of Inkscape are not correctly sorted by usefulness rating, current reviews as shown: + 8 of 8 people... + 4 of 4 people... + 3 of 3 people... + 4 of 4 people... <-- this review is out of order + 3 of 5 people... + 4. Close Software Center and install version 4.0.2 from natty-proposed. + 5. Open Software Center version 4.0.2 and navigate back to Inkscape. + 6. Verify that the reviews are now sorted correctly by usefulness, as shown for current reviews: + 8 of 8 people... + 4 of 4 people... + 4 of 4 people... + 3 of 3 people... + 3 of 5 people...
-- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/777583 Title: Reviews sorting should use upstream version -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list [email protected] https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs
