-- *Mar*The Gigantic Fatal Deception
To develop the scientific mind, the scientific attitude and scientific temperament, you have to assume that you are not part of nature, but an outside observer and indifferent spectator of nature, with license to tamper nature. At the basic level you consist of atoms, or positive electricity or protons in the nucleus and negative electricity or electrons hovering round the nucleus. The Universe is packed with electromagnetism creating the movement of molecules and atoms, with absolute zero as impossibility and nonexistent in the whole universe. But you have to assume that you are an outsider, a disconnected spectator, but with license to inflict the technology or the techno-logic on nature. This basic false and impossible assumption has taken over as the gigantic hypnotic spell, and you are sciencing away, scholaring away and destroying away nature, and calculating the destruction as economic growth. Day in and day out we are destroying nature and we are actually deceiving us that it is great advancement. The universities are turning out every year new corps of destroyers of nature, by creating them to do economics or the destruction. The students are stopped from living as natural humans but live as economic humans, the phantoms that live as machine.The economic man of economics is a machine only and is amenable to be treated with econometrics, or the mathematics that governs the life of the machine, the economic man. The life of the economic Man is a subject matter of Newtonian mechanics. When the universe is packed with electromagnetism, with actually vibrations of the pack as waves, and you being part of the pack, can you assume that you are not vibrating in and with the universe, and are not affected by the vibrations, which in reality are living? You have now emotionally become the outsider of the Biosphere repudiating the basic fact that every life form is an ecological, emotional and existential complement of every other life form. You simply livestock the Biosphere. You assume Social Darwinism in human societies, creating the rogue winners in the competition of life among the humans, and the Darwinist annihilation of every other life form in the war among the organisms of the Biosphere.We have to assume that the Biosphere as whole is destroying itself as the basic Darwinism. Policy means the definite life of action. Politics means the implementation of the policy. Today the policy of every country is to be ready for war, and politics means creating more and more destructive weapons, all now put under the subject called the ‘Political Science’, the Darwinist cult scholared and taught seriously. Politics today is strategizing the destruction of the other human societies called nations. Now the destruction is gathering momentum, and it may take to the unstoppable deluge. As it is ,with the takeover of every economic jobs by machines, there are no jobs in the economies, and a big economic depression is appearing in the horizon. Ecology and free nature are today’s saviours.Let us hope that every University becomes sane and starts the education that saves nature, and revives Ecology, on the terms of nature and not on the basis of Cartesian logic. We have to rehabilitate the basic emotional foundation of nature and realize that nature is not mechanical. YM Sarma Chat gpt Here’s my evaluation and edited version of your essay, *“The Gigantic Fatal Deception”*. ------------------------------ *Evaluation* - *Theme & Depth (9/10):* The essay strongly critiques the false assumption behind modern science and economics—that humans are detached from nature. You link this to destruction, mechanization of life, and political violence. The theme is profound, with a philosophical and ecological vision. - *Clarity & Flow (7/10):* The arguments are powerful, but the sentences are often long and densely packed. Some ideas repeat and could be more sharply expressed. - *Language & Style (7.5/10):* Passionate and evocative, but at times, the intensity overrides readability. Simplifying some sentences and balancing abstract ideas with concrete imagery would strengthen the impact. - *Overall Grade: A- (84/100).* This is a bold and insightful essay, though polishing the structure and flow would make it even more striking. ------------------------------ *Edited Version* *The Gigantic Fatal Deception* *By YM Sarma* To develop what we call a “scientific mind,” one is asked to assume a dangerous fiction: that the human being is not part of nature, but a detached observer, an indifferent spectator, with the license to tamper with nature. At the physical level, you consist of atoms—of protons and electrons—woven into the electromagnetic fabric of the universe. The cosmos is a living field of vibrations, where absolute stillness, or “absolute zero,” does not and cannot exist. You are part of this vibrant whole. Yet the scientific attitude demands that you imagine yourself outside it, a disconnected spectator armed with technology to dissect and dominate. This false assumption has cast a gigantic hypnotic spell. Under its influence, humanity is “sciencing away,” “scholaring away,” and “destroying away” nature—while calling that destruction *progress* or *economic growth*. Day by day, universities produce new corps of “economic humans,” trained not to live as natural beings but as phantoms of the machine world. The “economic man” is treated as a mechanism, governed by equations, econometrics, and Newtonian mechanics. But can a living being—vibrating with the universe itself—truly be reduced to a machine? Can we deny that every life form is an ecological, emotional, and existential complement of every other life form? By living as outsiders to the Biosphere, we repudiate our very essence, turning life into livestock and society into a Darwinist battlefield. Social Darwinism breeds rogue winners among humans while annihilating countless other species. It assumes that the Biosphere itself is condemned to self-destruction. Even our politics reflects this fatal deception. “Policy” is supposed to mean a life-guiding direction, and “politics” its implementation. Yet today, every national policy revolves around war-readiness, and politics is reduced to the manufacture of ever-deadlier weapons. Under the banner of “Political Science,” universities now legitimize a Darwinist cult of destruction. Nations strategize not for life, but for mutual annihilation. The destruction gathers momentum. Machines increasingly replace human work, ushering in the specter of global depression. The economic machine consumes both nature and humanity alike. Yet salvation is still possible. Ecology and free nature remain the true saviors of our time. The hope is that universities regain sanity, and education once again aligns itself with life—not with Cartesian abstractions, but with the living terms of nature itself. We must return to the emotional foundations of existence and remember: nature is not mechanical. ------------------------------ Would you like me to also *shorten this into a sharper article (around 700 words)*, so it’s more publishable in magazines or journals? -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Thatha_Patty" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/thatha_patty/CACDCHCKzcJc9xt6OZGw05VOZbWUcYAkkfVkxNSk_Za7LFG1fCw%40mail.gmail.com.
