Hi Ere, Thanks for your reply.
As currently we are looking at having a replica to do indexing, and another replica to be use for searching, these 2 requests looks like it can archive this purpose. Will this be implemented in the Solr 7.4 release? Regards, Edwin On 7 June 2018 at 16:00, Ere Maijala <ere.maij...@helsinki.fi> wrote: > Hi, > > What I did in SOLR-11982 was meant to be used with replica types. The idea > is that you could have a set of NRT replicas used for indexing and a set of > PULL replicas used for queries. That's the easiest way to split the work > since PULL replicas never do indexing work, and then you can say in the > queries that "shards.preference=replica.type:PULL" or have that as a > default parameter in solrconfig. SOLR-8146 is not needed for this. I > suppose now that SOLR-11982 is done, SOLR-8146 would only be needed to make > it easier to set the preferred replica type etc. > > SOLR-11982 also allows you to use replica location in node preference. The > nodes to use could be deduced from the cluster state and then you could use > shards.preference with replica.location. But that means the client has to > know which replicas to prefer. > > Regards, > Ere > > > Zheng Lin Edwin Yeo kirjoitti 4.6.2018 klo 19.09: > >> Hi, >> >> SOLR-8146 has not been updated since January last year, but I have just >> commented it. >> >> So we need both to be updated in order to achieve the full functionality >> of >> setting preferred replica for query/read? Currently, is there a way to >> achieve this by other means? >> >> Regards, >> Edwin >> >> On 4 June 2018 at 19:43, Ere Maijala <ere.maij...@helsinki.fi> wrote: >> >> Hi, >>> >>> Well, SOLR-11982 adds server-side support for part of what SOLR-8146 aims >>> to do (shards.preference=replica.location:[something]). It doesn't do >>> regular expressions or snitches at the moment, though it would be easy to >>> add. So, it looks to me like SOLR-8146 would need to be updated in this >>> regard. >>> >>> --Ere >>> >>> >>> Zheng Lin Edwin Yeo kirjoitti 4.6.2018 klo 12.45: >>> >>> Hi, >>>> >>>> Is there any similarities between these two requests in the JIRA >>>> regarding >>>> setting of prefer replica function? >>>> >>>> (SOLR-11982) Add support for preferReplicaTypes parameter >>>> >>>> (SOLR-8146) Allowing SolrJ CloudSolrClient to have preferred replica for >>>> query/read >>>> >>>> I am looking at setting one of the replica to be the preferred replica >>>> for >>>> query/read, and another replica to be use for indexing. >>>> >>>> I am using Solr 7.3.1 currently. >>>> >>>> Regards, >>>> Edwin >>>> >>>> >>>> -- >>> Ere Maijala >>> Kansalliskirjasto / The National Library of Finland >>> >>> >> > -- > Ere Maijala > Kansalliskirjasto / The National Library of Finland >
