-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

Erick,

(Sorry... hit sent inadvertently before completion...)

On 3/12/18 2:50 PM, Erick Erickson wrote:
> Something like:
> 
> ....solr/collection/query?q=chris shultz&defType=edismax&qf=all^10
> phonetic

Interesting. Looks like the "qf=all phonetic" would take the place of
my existing "df=all" parameter.

> The point of edismax is to take whatever the input is and
> distribute it among one or more fields defined by the "qf"
> parameter.

That's an entirely lucid explanation. That's not evident from reading
the official documentation :)

> In this case, it'll look for "chris" and "shultz" in both the
> "all" and "phonetic" fields. It would boost matches in the "all"
> field by 10, giving you an easy knob to tweak for "this field is
> more important than this other one".

Cool, like "if I spell it exactly right, I want that result to float
to the top"?

> You can combine  "fielded" searches, something like: 
> ....solr/collection/query?q=firstName:chris 
> shultz&defType=edismax&qf=all phonetic
> 
> would search for "shultz" in the "all" and "phonetic" fields while 
> searching for "chris" only in the "firstName" field.

Perfect.

> As you have noticed, there are a _lot_ of knobs to tweak when it
> comes to edismax, and the result of adding &debug=query to the URL
> can be...bewildering. But edismax was created exactly to spread the
> input out across multiple fields automatically.
> 
> You can also put these as defaults in your requesthandler in 
> solrconfig.xml. The "browse" handler in some of the examples will
> give you a template, I'd copy/paste from the "browse" handler to
> you main handler (usually "selsect"), as the "browse" handler is
> tied into the Velocity templating engine....

Since I'm taking the query from the user in my backend Java to convert
it into a Solr call, I'm comfortable doing everything in the Java code
itself. I'd actually rather not have too much automated stuff, because
then I think I'll confuse myself when using the Solr dashboard for
debugging, etc.

> To start, since there are a lot of parameters to tweak, I'd just
> start with the "qf" field (plus some boosts perhaps). Then move on
> to pf, pf2, pf3. mm will take a while to get your head around all
> by itself. I think once you see the basic operation, then the rest
> of the parameters will be easier to understand.
> 
> And I urge you to take it a little at a time, just use two fields
> and two terms and look at the result of &debug=query, the parsed
> query bits, 'cause each new thing you add adds a further
> complication. Fortunately you can just put different parameters on
> the URL and see the results for rapidly iterating.

Exactly :)

Thanks for the hints,
- -chris
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org
Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/
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=ehg4
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Reply via email to