Ok, thanks. I've added SOLR-9573 https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-9573
Regards, Markus -----Original message----- > From:Shalin Shekhar Mangar <shalinman...@gmail.com> > Sent: Tuesday 27th September 2016 16:04 > To: solr-user@lucene.apache.org > Subject: Re: Results not ordered by score and debug info is incorrect, crazy > > Wow, it took me some time to realize what you were referring to :-) > > The manual (or the reference guide page) is under construction and I didn't > finish that page. The sentence about faceting is just a copy/paste relic :) > I'll go fix that asap. > > I remember a bunch of Jira issues w.r.t NPE and distrib.singlePass which > have since been fixed. If you find something else, then please open a > issue. The distrib.singlePass approach reads all the stored fields from all > shards for all documents instead of just the top N docs. This can be > advantageous if you are returning a small number of fields but may cause > performance degradation if you are requesting all or a lot of fields. > > But coming back to this bug, it seems like debugQuery=true is behaving > incorrectly for the normal two phase search? Please open a jira issue. This > warrants more investigation. > > On Tue, Sep 27, 2016 at 6:26 PM, Markus Jelsma <markus.jel...@openindex.io> > wrote: > > > Shalin, that does the trick indeed! > > > > Also noted that the manual is incorrect, setting it to a blank or false > > value, did not disable my facets: > > If set to "true," this parameter enables facet counts in the query > > response. If set to "false" to a blank or missing value, this parameter > > disables faceting. None of the other parameters listed below will have any > > effect unless this parameter is set to "true." The default value is blank. > > > > In the past, i do remember some discussions about this parameter, and > > vaguely recall there were some drawbacks for this parameters, so i didn't > > enable it. > > > > The manual is not clear about this though, any recommendations? > > > > Thanks, > > Markus > > > > -----Original message----- > > > From:Shalin Shekhar Mangar <shalinman...@gmail.com> > > > Sent: Tuesday 27th September 2016 14:41 > > > To: solr-user@lucene.apache.org > > > Subject: Re: Results not ordered by score and debug info is incorrect, > > crazy > > > > > > This may be relevant or not, I am not sure but one difference between > > > fl=title_nl,score,id and fl=score,id is that the former executes a two > > pass > > > distributed search i.e. get ids, merge, get fields for top N docs but the > > > latter skips the "get fields" phase because it already has all the right > > > information. > > > > > > You can force the single pass for the first request as well by adding > > > distrib.singlePass=true as a request parameter. It might be interesting > > to > > > get that output as well and compare it with the others. > > > > > > On Tue, Sep 27, 2016 at 5:39 PM, Markus Jelsma < > > markus.jel...@openindex.io> > > > wrote: > > > > > > > Hi, > > > > > > > > I just spotted something weird, again. A regular search popped up a > > weird > > > > candidate for first result, so i've reproduced it on our production > > system. > > > > > > > > Digging deeper, it appears that the fl parameter has something to do > > with > > > > it. Not the order of results but the scores / explain in the debug > > section > > > > are different. This means i am not sure in what case the debugging > > > > information is really correcty. > > > > > > > > Check this out. These are the top four results with > > > > fl=title_nl,score,id&hl=false&facet=false&debugQuery=true& > > > > wt=xml&indent=true&q=misofonie&rows=4 > > > > > > > > <result name="response" numFound="26" start="0" maxScore="153.99518"> > > > > <doc> > > > > <str name="id">http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/179901/ > > > > website-over-misofonie-online/</str> > > > > <str name="title_nl">Website over misofonie online</str> > > > > <float name="score">153.99518</float></doc> > > > > <doc> > > > > <str name="id">http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/tag/misofonie/</str> > > > > <str name="title_nl">misofonie Archives - Gezondheid & Co</str> > > > > <float name="score">149.88002</float></doc> > > > > <doc> > > > > <str name="id">http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/263802/ > > > > misofonie-psychische-aandoening-is-behandelen/</str> > > > > <str name="title_nl">Misofonie: een psychische aandoening. Is het > > te > > > > behandelen? | Gezondheid & Co</str> > > > > <float name="score">147.82176</float></doc> > > > > <doc> > > > > <str name="id">http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/tag/ > > > > ereniging-misofonie-nl/</str> > > > > <str name="title_nl">ereniging Misofonie NL Archives - Gezondheid > > > > & Co</str> > > > > <float name="score">144.10309</float></doc> > > > > </result> > > > > > > > > And here's the truncated explain section for above request, notice > > that it > > > > is not ordered correctly and the scores are different than above: > > > > > > > > <str name="http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/179901/ > > > > website-over-misofonie-online/"> > > > > 148.65146 = sum of: > > > > 148.65146 = max plus 0.65 times others of: > > > > <str name="http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/tag/misofonie/";> > > > > 144.63885 = sum of: > > > > 144.63885 = max plus 0.65 times others of: > > > > <str name="http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/263802/ > > misofonie-psychische- > > > > aandoening-is-behandelen/"> > > > > 152.7493 = sum of: > > > > 152.7493 = max plus 0.65 times others of: > > > > <str name="http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/tag/ > > ereniging-misofonie-nl/"> > > > > 139.05501 = sum of: > > > > 139.05501 = max plus 0.65 times others of: > > > > > > > > Here's the other request with only the fl-parameter having a different > > > > value: fl=score,id&hl=false&facet=false&debugQuery=true&wt=xml& > > > > indent=true&q=misofonie&rows=4 > > > > > > > > <result name="response" numFound="26" start="0" maxScore="153.99518"> > > > > <doc> > > > > <str name="id">http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/179901/ > > > > website-over-misofonie-online/</str> > > > > <float name="score">153.99518</float></doc> > > > > <doc> > > > > <str name="id">http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/tag/misofonie/</str> > > > > <float name="score">149.88002</float></doc> > > > > <doc> > > > > <str name="id">http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/263802/ > > > > misofonie-psychische-aandoening-is-behandelen/</str> > > > > <float name="score">147.82176</float></doc> > > > > <doc> > > > > <str name="id">http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/tag/ > > > > ereniging-misofonie-nl/</str> > > > > <float name="score">144.10309</float></doc> > > > > </result> > > > > > > > > And here are the scores for this query, notice these are ordered > > > > descending, the ones above are not, also notice the scores are > > identical to > > > > that of the result set itself. > > > > > > > > <str name="http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/179901/ > > > > website-over-misofonie-online/"> > > > > 153.9952 = sum of: > > > > 153.9952 = max plus 0.65 times others of: > > > > <str name="http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/tag/misofonie/";> > > > > 149.88002 = sum of: > > > > 149.88002 = max plus 0.65 times others of: > > > > <str name="http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/263802/ > > misofonie-psychische- > > > > aandoening-is-behandelen/"> > > > > 147.82175 = sum of: > > > > 147.82175 = max plus 0.65 times others of: > > > > <str name="http://www.gezondheidenco.nl/tag/ > > ereniging-misofonie-nl/"> > > > > 144.10309 = sum of: > > > > 144.10309 = max plus 0.65 times others of: > > > > > > > > I am completely surprised to see this crazy behaviour. But i vaguely > > > > remeber something about this before, but cannot find references. > > > > > > > > Any idea? > > > > > > > > Thanks, > > > > Markus > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > Regards, > > > Shalin Shekhar Mangar. > > > > > > > > > -- > Regards, > Shalin Shekhar Mangar. >
