I've never reviewed that join query debug info - very interesting.
Break it all down - do the universe: query directly. Then see what the
results are and manually construct a query using the results of the join
query. If none of that works, try either a profiler to see where Solr is
spending most of its time, or try connecting a debugger (with source
code) such as Eclipse, to Solr and see where it is spending most of its
time.
Just some thoughts.
Upayavira
On Wed, Sep 9, 2015, at 04:24 PM, Russell Taylor wrote:
> Hi Upayavira,
> Here are a couple examples with debugQuery set.
> I've mislead Mikhail as the query times are getting longer as the list of
> ids gets bigger.
>
> Can you see a reason why where indexB has only 6 id's in its list it
> still takes 46 seconds?
>
> Ids=6
> {
> "responseHeader": {
> "status": 0,
> "QTime": 46849,
> "params": {
> "debugQuery": "true",
> "indent": "true",
> "start": "0",
> "q": "{!join from=sedolKey to=sedolKey
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:55AL86",
> "_": "1441810031117",
> "wt": "json"
> }
> },
> "response": {
> "numFound": 0,
> "start": 0,
> "docs": []
> },
> "debug": {
> "join": {
> "{!join from=sedolKey to=sedolKey
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:55AL86": {
> "time": 46848,
> "fromSetSize": 6,
> "toSetSize": 0,
> "fromTermCount": 11837043,
> "fromTermTotalDf": 11837043,
> "fromTermDirectCount": 11837043,
> "fromTermHits": 6,
> "fromTermHitsTotalDf": 6,
> "toTermHits": 0,
> "toTermHitsTotalDf": 0,
> "toTermDirectCount": 0,
> "smallSetsDeferred": 0,
> "toSetDocsAdded": 0
> }
> },
> "rawquerystring": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:55AL86",
> "querystring": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:55AL86",
> "parsedquery": "JoinQuery({!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:55AL86)",
> "parsedquery_toString": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:55AL86",
> "explain": {},
> "QParser": "",
> "timing": {
> "time": 46849,
> "prepare": {
> "time": 0,
> "query": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "facet": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "mlt": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "highlight": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "stats": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "expand": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "debug": {
> "time": 0
> }
> },
> "process": {
> "time": 46848,
> "query": {
> "time": 46848
> },
> "facet": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "mlt": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "highlight": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "stats": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "expand": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "debug": {
> "time": 0
> }
> }
> }
> }
> }
>
> ###########################################
> Ids=298
> {
> "responseHeader": {
> "status": 0,
> "QTime": 51570,
> "params": {
> "debugQuery": "true",
> "indent": "true",
> "q": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:16XO52",
> "_": "1441810442921",
> "wt": "json"
> }
> },
> "response": {
> "numFound": 0,
> "start": 0,
> "docs": []
> },
> "debug": {
> "join": {
> "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:16XO52": {
> "time": 51570,
> "fromSetSize": 298,
> "toSetSize": 0,
> "fromTermCount": 11837043,
> "fromTermTotalDf": 11837043,
> "fromTermDirectCount": 11837043,
> "fromTermHits": 298,
> "fromTermHitsTotalDf": 298,
> "toTermHits": 0,
> "toTermHitsTotalDf": 0,
> "toTermDirectCount": 0,
> "smallSetsDeferred": 0,
> "toSetDocsAdded": 0
> }
> },
> "rawquerystring": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:16XO52",
> "querystring": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:16XO52",
> "parsedquery": "JoinQuery({!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:16XO52)",
> "parsedquery_toString": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:16XO52",
> "explain": {},
> "QParser": "",
> "timing": {
> "time": 51570,
> "prepare": {
> "time": 0,
> "query": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "facet": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "mlt": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "highlight": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "stats": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "expand": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "debug": {
> "time": 0
> }
> },
> "process": {
> "time": 51570,
> "query": {
> "time": 51570
> },
> "facet": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "mlt": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "highlight": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "stats": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "expand": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "debug": {
> "time": 0
> }
> }
> }
> }
> }
>
> ###################################################################
> Id's = 424088
> "debug": {
> "join": {
> "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:LARGE": {
> "time": 44386,
> "fromSetSize": 424088,
> "toSetSize": 892314,
> "fromTermCount": 11837043,
> "fromTermTotalDf": 11837043,
> "fromTermDirectCount": 11837043,
> "fromTermHits": 420365,
> "fromTermHitsTotalDf": 420365,
> "toTermHits": 57074,
> "toTermHitsTotalDf": 944597,
> "toTermDirectCount": 55722,
> "smallSetsDeferred": 1352,
> "toSetDocsAdded": 892314
> }
> },
> "rawquerystring": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:LARGE",
> "querystring": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:LARGE",
> "parsedquery": "JoinQuery({!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:LARGE)",
> "parsedquery_toString": "{!join from=longValue to=longValue
> fromIndex=indexB}universe:LARGE",
> "explain": {
> "2000000076769983": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@483489aa , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n",
> "2000000076769984": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@118f9aef , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n",
> "2000000076769985": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@7a5d18ac , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n",
> "2000000076769986": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@6d601adc , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n",
> "2000000076769987": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@2e262f31 , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n",
> "2000000076769988": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@4b200302 , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n",
> "2000000076769989": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@569910d2 , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n",
> "2000000076770006": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@635a3843 , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n",
> "2000000076770007": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@5b438a92 , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n",
> "2000000076770029": "\n1.0 = (MATCH)
> org.apache.solr.search.JoinQuery$JoinQueryWeight@31d9c4c , product
> of:\n 1.0 = boost\n 1.0 = queryNorm\n"
> },
> "QParser": "",
> "timing": {
> "time": 480859,
> "prepare": {
> "time": 0,
> "query": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "facet": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "mlt": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "highlight": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "stats": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "expand": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "debug": {
> "time": 0
> }
> },
> "process": {
> "time": 480859,
> "query": {
> "time": 43737
> },
> "facet": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "mlt": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "highlight": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "stats": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "expand": {
> "time": 0
> },
> "debug": {
> "time": 437122
> }
> }
> }
> }
> }
>
>
> Thanks
>
>
> Russ.
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Upayavira [mailto:u...@odoko.co.uk]
> Sent: 09 September 2015 13:02
> To: solr-user@lucene.apache.org
> Subject: Re: Solr Join between two indexes taking too long.
>
> To explain what a join does:
>
> It goes over to the joined index, and executes a query. This results in a
> list of "ids" that will be used to do a search on the main index. The
> more of these ids there are, the worse performance will be. Thus, if you
> have 100k documents that match in the join core, you will be doing a 100k
> term search, which will invariably be painful, because the more terms you
> include in the search, the slower it will be.
>
> How many matching docs do you have on the other side of your query?
>
> Upayavira
>
> On Tue, Sep 8, 2015, at 02:09 PM, Russell Taylor wrote:
> > Hi,
> > I hope somebody can help.
> >
> > We have two indexes, one which holds the descriptive data and the
> > other one which holds lists of docs which are of a certain type
> > (called universes in our world). They need to be joined together to
> > show a list of data from indexA where a filtered indexB (by
> > universe:value) has matching longs (The join field).
> >
> > At the moment the query is taking 55 seconds we need to get it under a
> > second, any help most appreciated.
> >
> > INDEXES:
> >
> > Index a (primary index)
> > 31 million docs with a converted alphanumeric to a long value with a
> > possible 10 million unique values.
> >
> > Index B (the joined index)
> > 250 million documents with a converted alphanumeric to a long value
> > with a possible 10 million unique values.
> > IndexB is filtered by universe which could be between 1 and 500,000 docs.
> >
> > QUERY:
> > http://127.0.0.1:8080/solr/indexA/select?q={!join+from=longValue+to=lo
> > ngValue+fromIndex=IndexB}universe:<http://127.0.0.1:8080/solr/indexA/s
> > elect?q=%7b!join+from=longValue+to=longValue+fromIndex=IndexB%7duniver
> > se:>universeValue
> >
> > Qtime is 55 seconds for either a universe of 5 docs or 500,000 docs.
> >
> >
> >
> > Thanks
> >
> >
> > Russ.
> >
> >
> > *******************************************************
> > This message (including any files transmitted with it) may contain
> > confidential and/or proprietary information, is the property of
> > Interactive Data Corporation and/or its subsidiaries, and is directed
> > only to the addressee(s). If you are not the designated recipient or
> > have reason to believe you received this message in error, please
> > delete this message from your system and notify the sender
> > immediately. An unintended recipient's disclosure, copying,
> > distribution, or use of this message or any attachments is prohibited and
> > may be unlawful.
> > *******************************************************
>
>
> *******************************************************
> This message (including any files transmitted with it) may contain
> confidential and/or proprietary information, is the property of
> Interactive Data Corporation and/or its subsidiaries, and is directed
> only to the addressee(s). If you are not the designated recipient or have
> reason to believe you received this message in error, please delete this
> message from your system and notify the sender immediately. An unintended
> recipient's disclosure, copying, distribution, or use of this message or
> any attachments is prohibited and may be unlawful.
> *******************************************************
>
