Hello,

> With all do respect, I really think the problem is largely underestimated here, and is far more complex then these suggestions...unless we are talking about 100.000 documents, couple of users, and updating ones a day. If you want millions of documents, facetted authorized navigation including counting and every second a new indexed document which should be reflected in the result instantly and changing authorisations....the problem isn't relatively easy to solve anymore :-)

When I had those kind of problems (less complex) with lucene, the only idea was to filter from the front-end, according to the ACL policy. Lucene docs and fields weren't protected, but tagged. Searching was always applied with a field "audience", with hierarchical values like "public, reserved, protected, secret", so that a "public" document has the "secret" value also, to be found with a "audience:secret", according to the rights of the user who searchs. For the fields, the not allowed ones for some users where striped.

May be you can have a look to the xmldb Exist ? The search engine, xquery based, is not focused on the same goals as lucene, but I can promise you that all queries will never return results from documents you are not allowed to read.


--
Frédéric Glorieux
École nationale des chartes
direction des nouvelles technologies et de l'informatique

Reply via email to