W dniu 4.01.2024 o 07:56, Loris Bennett pisze:
Hi Kamil, Kamil Wilczek <km...@mimuw.edu.pl> writes:Dear All, I have a question regarding the fair-share factor of the multifactor priority algorithm. My current understanding is that the fair-share makes sure that different *accounts* have a fair share of the computational power. But what if my organisation structure is flat and I have only one account where all my user reside. Is fair-share algorithm working in this situation -- does it take into account users (associations) from this single account, and tries to assing a fair-factor to each user? Or each user from this account have the same fair-factor at each iteration? And what if I have, say 3 accounts, but I do not wan't to calculate fair-share between accounts, but between all associations from all 3 accounts? In other words, is there a fair-share factor for users/associations instead of accounts? Kind regardsWe have a similar situation. We do in fact have an account for each research group and the groups are associated with institutes and departments, but we use FairShare=parent so that all users are given the same number of shares and thus treated equally by the fair-share mechanism.
Hi Loris, but is the "FairShare=parent" still works for the Fair Tree, which is the default algorithm since 19.05? I can find this option only for the Classic Fair Share. And I'm trying to differentiate between users, so that they are not treated equally by the algorithm. Heavy users should have a lower factor. I think I could create an account for each user, but is that a common practice and not an overkill? I'm also trying to understand the Fair Tree, because there is a section when it says that users can have different factors if their common ancestor accounts have different factors. But what if they have only one single common ancestor? Would then association/users still be sorted by the fair-factor? Kind regards, --
Cheers, Loris
-- Kamil Wilczek [https://keys.openpgp.org/] [D415917E84B8DA5A60E853B6E676ED061316B69B]
OpenPGP_signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
