Hi Greg,

Thank you! The key was to use integer boolean instead of true/false. It seems 
this is inconsistent for job_desc elements as some use true/false. Have a great 
one!

Best,
Chris
 
-- 
Christopher Coffey
High-Performance Computing
Northern Arizona University
928-523-1167
 
 

On 2/18/22, 9:09 PM, "slurm-users on behalf of Greg Wickham" 
<slurm-users-boun...@lists.schedmd.com on behalf of greg.wick...@kaust.edu.sa> 
wrote:

    Hi Chris,

    You mentioned “But trials using this do not seem to be fruitful so far.” . 
. why?

    In our job_submit.lua there is:


        if job_desc.shared == 0 then
          slurm.user_msg("exclusive access is not permitted with GPU jobs.")
          slurm.user_msg("Remove '--exclusive' from your job submission script")
          return ESLURM_NOT_SUPPORTED
        end

    and testing:

    $ srun --exclusive --time 00:10:00 --gres gpu:1 --pty /bin/bash -i 
    srun: error: exclusive access is not permitted with GPU jobs.
    srun: error: Remove '--exclusive' from your job submission script
    srun: error: Unable to allocate resources: Requested operation is presently 
disabled

    In slurm.h the job_descriptor struct has:

            uint16_t shared;        /* 2 if the job can only share nodes with 
other
                                     *   jobs owned by that user,
                                     * 1 if job can share nodes with other jobs,
                                     * 0 if job needs exclusive access to the 
node,
                                     * or NO_VAL to accept the system default.
                                     * SHARED_FORCE to eliminate user control. 
*/

    If there’s a case where using “.shared” isn’t working please let us know.

       -Greg


    From: slurm-users <slurm-users-boun...@lists.schedmd.com> on behalf of 
Christopher Benjamin Coffey <chris.cof...@nau.edu>
    Date: Saturday, 19 February 2022 at 3:17 am
    To: slurm-users <slurm-users@lists.schedmd.com>
    Subject: [EXTERNAL] [slurm-users] Can job submit plugin detect 
"--exclusive" ?

    Hello!

    The job_submit plugin doesn't appear to have a way to detect whether a user 
requested "--exclusive". Can someone confirm this? Going through the code: 
src/plugins/job_submit/lua/job_submit_lua.c I don't see anything related. 
Potentially "shared" could be possible
     in some way. But trials using this do not seem to be fruitful so far.

    If a user requests --exclusive, I'd like to append "--exclude=<nodes>" on 
to their job request to keep them off of certain nodes. For instance, we have 
our gpu nodes in a default partition with a high priority so that jobs don't 
land on them until last. And
     this is the same for our highmem nodes. Normally this works fine, but if 
someone asks for "--exclusive" this will land on these nodes quite often 
unfortunately.

    Any ideas? Of course, I could take these nodes out of the partition, yet 
I'd like to see if something like this would be possible.

    Thanks! :)

    Best,
    Chris

    -- 
    Christopher Coffey
    High-Performance Computing
    Northern Arizona University
    928-523-1167





Reply via email to