Re: Help me make backups better on GNU/Linux

2013-03-19 Thread Gordon Messmer
On 03/19/2013 05:13 PM, Jorge Fábregas wrote: The thing is to separate the snapshotting & the quiescing activities so that the quiescing works regardless of the snapshot technology being used. Is this more or less what you're doing? Yes! It might be as simple as: for x in /usr/lib/snapshot

Re: Help me make backups better on GNU/Linux

2013-03-19 Thread Jorge Fábregas
On 03/19/2013 02:29 AM, Gordon Messmer wrote: > After publicly bitching about Linux's poor backup infrastructure for the > hundredth time, I decided to write a common system for making snapshots. Hi, This is interesting since we have nothing like the VSS infrastructure on Windows. My experienc

Re: Help me make backups better on GNU/Linux

2013-03-19 Thread Gordon Messmer
On 03/19/2013 04:22 AM, Neal Becker wrote: check out obnam. I'm very pleased with it. That's not at all the same thing. You cannot back up files in active use safely. If you have a SQL server, for instance, you need to either shut it down or quiesce the data files for the entire duration o

Re: Help me make backups better on GNU/Linux

2013-03-19 Thread Neal Becker
Gordon Messmer wrote: > After publicly bitching about Linux's poor backup infrastructure for the > hundredth time, I decided to write a common system for making snapshots. > I've written the first iteration in bash. It took one day to do most of > the work, and then a few hours of testing and fix

Help me make backups better on GNU/Linux

2013-03-18 Thread Gordon Messmer
After publicly bitching about Linux's poor backup infrastructure for the hundredth time, I decided to write a common system for making snapshots. I've written the first iteration in bash. It took one day to do most of the work, and then a few hours of testing and fixing to get things working r